Can you really consider Pacquiao a 8 division champ when he never........

[Johnnyrider]

If you cannot be considered champion unless you beat the top guy then there would only be one champion in each weight class.Unfortunately that's not the case.One of the biggest reasons boxing has lost so many fans

[mcdonalds]

If you cannot be considered champion unless you beat the top guy then there would only be one champion in each weight class.Unfortunately that's not the case.One of the biggest reasons boxing has lost so many fans

Thats how it should be

[Pigeons]

He's a 6-division world champion, but an 8-division world or lineal champion.

[KillaMane26]

How much weight does Broner division titles hold? If not much u have to say the same about Manny. Lol he beat Margirto for that 154 strap??

[DuckAdonis]

Wtf are you talking about? He beat alot of great fighters. 8 division/6 division...Won't change his all-time great status to me

[mcdonalds]

Wtf are you talking about? He beat alot of great fighters. 8 division/6 division...Won't change his all-time great status to me

He never beat the top guy at those weight classes. That's all im trying to say, not trying to discredit his wins.

[DuckAdonis]

He never beat the top guy at those weight classes. That's all im trying to say, not trying to discredit his wins.

Based on what? Public opinion...The Ring ratings? Elaborate a bit

[mcdonalds]

Based on what? Public opinion...The Ring ratings? Elaborate a bit

You know by beating the man who beat the man.....

You can call it lineal if you want, but in a lot of cases the best guy didn't even have the lineal title so the title itself is not that important...

135- Didn't happen

147- Didn't happen

154- Didn't happen

[mcdonalds]

He's a 6-division world champion, but an 8-division world or lineal champion.

So, can you really consider him a 6 division champ when he's never beaten the top guy at 135, 147 and 154?

[Pigeons]

So, can you really consider him a 6 division champ when he's never beaten the top guy at 135, 147 and 154?

Boxing's not about beating the best, it's about making the most money.