Joe calzaghe v canelo alvarez who wins at 168

[monkeyboy]

You act like Nelo never beat up any one bigger than him....LOL....Nelo's body shots puts joke calslappy in a race track.

Moronic nickname for fighter? Check.
Self appointed LOL? Check.
Exceedingly simplistic argument that proves nothing? Check.
Boxingscene fanboy/hater? Check!

Canelo has never cleanly and clearly beaten an excellent fighter with a tricky style, least of all one who has as many physical advantages as a lifetime super middle weight who has coped with some major punchers.

I’m sorry that you seem defensive but no matter how good someone is, styles make fights. Canelo’s good but on current assessment he is not beating a HOF super middleweight with Calzaghe’s skill set. Give him a few decent super middles and we will see.

[TakeAymz]

Calzaghe wins this one

[j.razor]

Moronic nickname for fighter? Check.
Self appointed LOL? Check.
Exceedingly simplistic argument that proves nothing? Check.
Boxingscene fanboy/hater? Check!

Canelo has never cleanly and clearly beaten an excellent fighter with a tricky style, least of all one who has as many physical advantages as a lifetime super middle weight who has coped with some major punchers.

I’m sorry that you seem defensive but no matter how good someone is, styles make fights. Canelo’s good but on current assessment he is not beating a HOF super middleweight with Calzaghe’s skill set. Give him a few decent super middles and we will see.

You pretending. Look at joke calslappy's resume. He also got put on his ass & lost to a 43 year old Hopkins. You a fanboy that "Don't Know Shet Bout Boxing."

[j.razor]

Calzaghe wins this one

His resume says different.

[chrisJS]

I've found it funny how Mayweather fanboys (who are usually not boxing fans btw they just ********** over Floyd and relate everything to him) try and portray Canelo as some legendary all-time great fighter because Mayweather got a win over him when he was green, nowhere near ready for a big fight and completely weight-drained and they think the wins grows legs LOL. Reason being is that Mayweather fought two great fighters how whole career in Marquez & Pacquaio. The Marquez win basically doesn't count since Marquez (who'd just jumped two divisions in quick succession) jumped another two weights and Floyd flaked on the weight (for perspective two years prior Marquez was at 126 age 33, Floyd at 154 having filled out as a welterweight in his 20's) so you're left with Pacquaio who was already washed up and fanboys said he ****** anyway so you can lose that one so we are left with two formerly elites in Mosley (who'd been out 16 months was 38/39 and was like 5-5 coming in had one good win in 10 years and did nothing after) and De La Hoya who'd been losing as many as winning, been rusty as hell and De La Hoya actually beat Floyd too LOL. Fishnets also did nothing after that fight too which shows he was shot.

That's why Canelo has a bunch of dumbass casuals rooting him on LOL because these childish names like TBE look hilarious when you measure him with fighters who actually tested themselves against prime guys, actually became undisputed champions, had lengthy reigns etc; etc;

[IronDanHamza]

Calzaghe ruined that dudes life when he whupped Lacy (who he loved like Charlo) and then Hopkins. Hopkins wanted to quit and was in survival mode. Dude thinks Charlo and Judah are better than Calzaghe LMFAO! Hence why he’s on ignore.

FYI Calzaghe would dominate Floyd too. Imagine Floyd in 2007 against Calzaghe LOL even his PEDs couldn’t make it competitive.

Well yeah probably because Floyd is like 3 weight classes smaller.

[chrisJS]

Well yeah probably because Floyd is like 3 weight classes smaller.

But he'd still lose right? My point is many nutthuggers can't even acknowledge or accept that. Mayweather (from vs. Cotto, Canelo, De La Hoya) was only two divisions lower than Calzaghe from Lacy or Kessler so it's really just like Mayweather vs. Marquez.

[j.razor]

I've found it funny how Mayweather fanboys (who are usually not boxing fans btw they just ********** over Floyd and relate everything to him) try and portray Canelo as some legendary all-time great fighter because Mayweather got a win over him when he was green, nowhere near ready for a big fight and completely weight-drained and they think the wins grows legs LOL. Reason being is that Mayweather fought two great fighters how whole career in Marquez & Pacquaio. The Marquez win basically doesn't count since Marquez (who'd just jumped two divisions in quick succession) jumped another two weights and Floyd flaked on the weight (for perspective two years prior Marquez was at 126 age 33, Floyd at 154 having filled out as a welterweight in his 20's) so you're left with Pacquaio who was already washed up and fanboys said he ****** anyway so you can lose that one so we are left with two formerly elites in Mosley (who'd been out 16 months was 38/39 and was like 5-5 coming in had one good win in 10 years and did nothing after) and De La Hoya who'd been losing as many as winning, been rusty as hell and De La Hoya actually beat Floyd too LOL. Fishnets also did nothing after that fight too which shows he was shot.

That's why Canelo has a bunch of dumbass casuals rooting him on LOL because these childish names like TBE look hilarious when you measure him with fighters who actually tested themselves against prime guys, actually became undisputed champions, had lengthy reigns etc; etc;

Get your salty ass journalism out of here you clown. You mad cuz you shet on T.B.E. for the last 15 years & got it ALL WRONG....LMMFAO! FOH with your dumb shet.

[DreamFighter]

I've found it funny how Mayweather fanboys (who are usually not boxing fans btw they just ********** over Floyd and relate everything to him) try and portray Canelo as some legendary all-time great fighter because Mayweather got a win over him when he was green, nowhere near ready for a big fight and completely weight-drained and they think the wins grows legs LOL. Reason being is that Mayweather fought two great fighters how whole career in Marquez & Pacquaio. The Marquez win basically doesn't count since Marquez (who'd just jumped two divisions in quick succession) jumped another two weights and Floyd flaked on the weight (for perspective two years prior Marquez was at 126 age 33, Floyd at 154 having filled out as a welterweight in his 20's) so you're left with Pacquaio who was already washed up and fanboys said he ****** anyway so you can lose that one so we are left with two formerly elites in Mosley (who'd been out 16 months was 38/39 and was like 5-5 coming in had one good win in 10 years and did nothing after) and De La Hoya who'd been losing as many as winning, been rusty as hell and De La Hoya actually beat Floyd too LOL. Fishnets also did nothing after that fight too which shows he was shot.

That's why Canelo has a bunch of dumbass casuals rooting him on LOL because these childish names like TBE look hilarious when you measure him with fighters who actually tested themselves against prime guys, actually became undisputed champions, had lengthy reigns etc; etc;

yeh funny man, a guy whose best win is a 43 year old is better than a top 30atg in may. lol

[chrisJS]

yeh funny man, a guy whose best win is a 43 year old is better than a top 30atg in may. lol

I'm not saying that. I'm saying he'd thrash him in the ring though. I think Mayweather is a top 50 all-time great and Calzaghe I'd probably put in the top 100 barely. His best win is Kessler probably and that is a better win thn any Floyd win IMO and perhaps so too is his Hopkins win on the account that Hopkins was coming off two big wins and scored a few after.

I've never picked against either in a fight and consider both to have had disappointing level of competition overall. I was a Mayweather fan before probably anyone here and also have seen him live far more than anyone here.