If Taylor wins=#1 P4P??

[K-DOGG]

...and PBF is #1 because he does present the image of an unbeateable fighter...whether he is or not. He would be a favorite in just about any match you could put him in between 140 and 154...tell me I'm wrong.

Taylor was a 3-1 underdog when the Wright fight was announced.

Nuff said.

[K-DOGG]

Again you forget that Hopkins & Wright are not fighters you gonna look good against, I don't care if you put Robinson against Hopkins, he will not look good.

Your performance theory is not making any sense.

Agreed that Hopkins is not a guy you can look good against; but because there are questions surrounding those fights, Taylor was NOT the clear winner....and if he didn't have skin on his teeth, he wouldn't have won them. Dominance is what it's all about....to be the best without question. Taylor is not....not yet. The "?" has to be removed.

[GunStar]

I mentioned Joppy because he's the only other fighter of note that Taylor has ever fought. But, yes, I agree there's no version of Joppy Taylor wouldn't have beaten. Joppy's one of the most overrated fighters to come along in a long time. His biggest wins were over Julio Caesar Green..who beat him...and an 82 year old Roberto Duran.

Raul Marquez is a better fighter then Joppy. Taylor was the first man to put Marquez down.

[GunStar]

Agreed that Hopkins is not a guy you can look good against; but because there are questions surrounding those fights, Taylor was NOT the clear winner....and if he didn't have skin on his teeth, he wouldn't have won them. Dominance is what it's all about....to be the best without question. Taylor is not....not yet. The "?" has to be removed.

The first fight was not even close in my opinion, Hopkins lost the first 8 rounds, the second fight was a little closer, still I had Taylor winning 7 rounds.

[guru]

...and PBF is #1 because he does present the image of an unbeateable fighter...whether he is or not. He would be a favorite in just about any match you could put him in between 140 and 154...tell me I'm wrong.

Taylor was a 3-1 underdog when the Wright fight was announced.

Nuff said.

that's why people have pbf at #1 now, but if taylor beats wright decisively he won't be an underdog to anyone either...

[Smokin']

**** all this p4p ****. It's just a ****** American term used for AMERICAN fighters. Who gives a ****. I know who the real fighters are anyways.

[guru]

PBF already beat 3 fighters on the P4P list, Zab on on there last year, as well as Corrales and JLC

zab should not have been on anyones p4p list when he fought floyd, he had just lost

[K-DOGG]

that's why people have pbf at #1 now, but if taylor beats wright decisively he won't be an underdog to anyone either...

No argument, there. It all depends on what Taylor does against Wright. If he pleads his case right...he's right up there with Floyd.

[K-DOGG]

Raul Marquez is a better fighter then Joppy. Taylor was the first man to put Marquez down.

At that stage in his career, maybe; but Raul was still stopped by Yori Boy Campas and Vargas....jr. middleweights. Still, the question is moot. Joppy, at least, was a natural middleweight.

[GunStar]

At that stage in his career, maybe; but Raul was still stopped by Yori Boy Campas and Vargas....jr. middleweights. Still, the question is moot. Joppy, at least, was a natural middleweight.

Being stopped is a different then being knocked down.