What was the Better Win- Floyd-Marquez or Loma-Rigo?

[Tony Trick-Pony]

In both instances you had a p4p guy in Floyd and Loma facing a smaller p4p guy in Marquez and Rigo.

Loma made the 130 pound limit. Floyd did not.

Marquez had never fought above 135. He jumped 12 pounds to fight Floyd.

Rigo had never fought above 122. He jumped 8 pounds to face Loma.

Floyd easily beat Marquez, dropping him en route to a UD.

Loma made Rigo quit after six, winning every round except for possibly the first.

How can Loma's NOT be more impressive, given the similarities?

[TonyGe]

Neither they both were disappointing.

[daggum]

well lets pretend we are floyd fans for a second( smash yourself in the head for an hour so you lose 100 iq points) ok now. floyd fans love undefeated fighters right? so advantage rigo. floyd fans love slick fighters so massive advantage rigo. now that we are floyd fans we should be consistent and say beating rigo is the much better win.

[THEFRESHBRAWLER]

Neither. That was just a fight for Floyd to get in shape and lose the ring rust

[THEFRESHBRAWLER]

well lets pretend we are floyd fans for a second( smash yourself in the head for an hour so you lose 100 iq points) ok now. floyd fans love undefeated fighters right? so advantage rigo. floyd fans love slick fighters so massive advantage rigo. now that we are floyd fans we should be consistent and say beating rigo is the much better win.

Floyd fans floyd fans Floyd fans Floyd fans smh pathetic. Why do you care so much about his fans?

[daggum]

Floyd fans floyd fans Floyd fans Floyd fans smh pathetic. Why do you care so much about his fans?

excuse me? just because i am a fan of slick boxing doesn't make me pathetic. i know you like slow bums like ggg and kovalev but rigo, ward, and floyd are the best fighters around. dont be jealous. i am a fan of floyd and probably his biggest fan but i am also consistent. rigo is a slick fighter. rigo was undefeated(most important thing in boxing) therefore beating rigo is much better than beating marquez.

[RetroSpeed05]

Not only that but no one thought JMM had a chance, a good amount had Rigo winning. Or like they say "break his jaw" just like he did the rest.

[THEFRESHBRAWLER]

excuse me? just because i am a fan of slick boxing doesn't make me pathetic. i know you like slow bums like ggg and kovalev but rigo, ward, and floyd are the best fighters around. dont be jealous. i am a fan of floyd and probably his biggest fan but i am also consistent. rigo is a slick fighter. rigo was undefeated(most important thing in boxing) therefore beating rigo is much better than beating marquez.

They both were ok wins imo Lomachenco is great but he is not better than Floyd. What is so controversial about that?

[iamboxing]

well lets pretend we are floyd fans for a second( smash yourself in the head for an hour so you lose 100 iq points)

[Sugar Adam Ali]

I rate them about the same..

A legit p4p #1 guy fighting a fellow p4p elite but a champ from smaller weight class..