Tweet
What are the best wins of the last 20 years? Got to factor in some circumstances like just because it's a huge event doesn't elevate it if one of the guys far removed from his best much like Lewis-Tyson. Or if one of the fighters has been inactive for a while say a 12 month cut off that should factor in. Catch weights also shouldn't really shouldn't be strongly considered so like Hopkins-Wright, Cotto-Pacquaio for example. Controversial decisions shouldn't really be considered either so like De La Hoya-Whitaker.
Circumstances that make it great are simple - quality of the opponent and the form he brought into the ring and recent record, whether the fighter is great or not and the task at hand for example Douglas-Tyson would qualify but obviously that's 27 years ago.
I broke it down to the following :- (no order)
Hopkins-Trinidad
Marquez-Pacquaio IV
Pacquaio-Barrera I
Barrera-Morales III
Morales-Pacquaio I
Target-Jones II
Those would be my choices for the absolute best given the form, quality of the fighters (the loser was a clearly great fighter) activity level, stage of their careers and performance.
I'd then add
Chocolatito-Rungvisai II
Mosley-De La Hoya I
Forrest-Mosley I
Hopkins-Tarver
Marquez-Barrera
Pacquaio-Morales II
Rafael Marquez-Vazquez I
Vazquez-Rafael Marquez II
Barrera-Hamed
I think these one (with the exception of JMM-MAB) involve fighters who aren't quite great but almost there. Of course Morales-Pacquaio II is but Morales wear and tear showed and a poor showing against Raheem.
So factored in I'd take that one down and probably Choco-Rungvisai due to Choco being a little high up in weight and wear and tear and probably Hopkins-Tarver. It's nitpicking but you've got to when narrowing down a list like this.
My 10 would be
Marquez-Pacquaio IV
Pacquaio-Barrera I
Hopkins-Trinidad
Tarver-Jones II
Morales-Pacquaio I
Barrera-Morales III
Forrest-Mosley I
Mosley-De La Hoya I
Marquez-Barrera
Rafa-Vazquez I
In somewhat of an order.
Circumstances that make it great are simple - quality of the opponent and the form he brought into the ring and recent record, whether the fighter is great or not and the task at hand for example Douglas-Tyson would qualify but obviously that's 27 years ago.
I broke it down to the following :- (no order)
Hopkins-Trinidad
Marquez-Pacquaio IV
Pacquaio-Barrera I
Barrera-Morales III
Morales-Pacquaio I
Target-Jones II
Those would be my choices for the absolute best given the form, quality of the fighters (the loser was a clearly great fighter) activity level, stage of their careers and performance.
I'd then add
Chocolatito-Rungvisai II
Mosley-De La Hoya I
Forrest-Mosley I
Hopkins-Tarver
Marquez-Barrera
Pacquaio-Morales II
Rafael Marquez-Vazquez I
Vazquez-Rafael Marquez II
Barrera-Hamed
I think these one (with the exception of JMM-MAB) involve fighters who aren't quite great but almost there. Of course Morales-Pacquaio II is but Morales wear and tear showed and a poor showing against Raheem.
So factored in I'd take that one down and probably Choco-Rungvisai due to Choco being a little high up in weight and wear and tear and probably Hopkins-Tarver. It's nitpicking but you've got to when narrowing down a list like this.
My 10 would be
Marquez-Pacquaio IV
Pacquaio-Barrera I
Hopkins-Trinidad
Tarver-Jones II
Morales-Pacquaio I
Barrera-Morales III
Forrest-Mosley I
Mosley-De La Hoya I
Marquez-Barrera
Rafa-Vazquez I
In somewhat of an order.
Comment