You Can't Be P4P #1 With Zero Elite Wins...

[Madison Boxing]

well i guess youve just ruled terence crawford out of the running then. Or does viktor postol (who just went life and death with some absolute nobody) count as an elite win all of a sudden?

[The Comic DON]

You're apparently the type of guy I was referring to. It's ok, you can't can spin it however you like to make yourselves feel better. I'm ok putting GG as #1 and don't need to snub him.
Not afraid of being honest.

But your post was the exact opposite of an honesty friend. Why you gotta make stuff up instead of just sticking to the facts?

[hugh grant]

You can beat atg fighters who are in prime yet still not be no1 though.
PAC beat Barrera but Floyd was ranked no1 PFP I believe without haven beaten anyone

[SilverMiles]

But your post was the exact opposite of an honesty friend. Why you gotta make stuff up instead of just sticking to the facts?

Your wasting your time. When it comes to Redd and Ward it's like internet love affair. But he's a good poster most other times yet still he's a hardcore Ward fanboy.

[Mr.Fantastic]

...which is why Golovkin will have to wait til May for a crack at it.

At least Loma is fighting Rigo in December, so a W there makes him legit.

Right now, Bud is top dawg.

Mikey, Errol, Thurman, and AJ round out my top 5.

What elite win has Bud done? FYI this is coming from someone that likes him but not blind.

[The Comic DON]

Your wasting your time. When it comes to Redd and Ward it's like internet love affair. But he's a good poster most other times yet still he's a hardcore Ward fanboy.

I see that now, can't trust them fanboys to keep it 100.

It's not like Ward was never #1 but he wants to shift the timeframe from April to November.

SAD.

[BillyBoxing]

...which is why Golovkin will have to wait til May for a crack at it.

At least Loma is fighting Rigo in December, so a W there makes him legit.

Right now, Bud is top dawg.

Mikey, Errol, Thurman, and AJ round out my top 5.

P4P lists sucks especially yours.

What makes Errol better P4P than Loma or Rigo? (Since you don't have them in your top 5)

How the hell is this camel faced southpaw better than those two amateur legends.

Who did Errol Spence beat except the remaining pieces of Kell Brook who was coming from a TKO loss followed by a long lay off recovering from a bad injury.

[Jsmooth9876]

Hilarious he says GGG can't have it but Crawford can? I love Crawford but he ain't beat no elite guys.

[Feint First]

Based on this criteria Errol Spence is #1 P4P. He has the most elite win in boxing, KO over the champ Brook in his hometown.

Brook KO > Russell Jr, inactive Walters, old small Rigo

[DuckAdonis]

Its not like Crawford has faced any elite guys yet lol