Kell Brook was never really that good

[redmish]

Here we go again. Losing 2 fights against top level opponents does not make him a bad fighter. Errol Spence is a very good fighter and might go on to be P4P number 1 and GGG is always in the P4P argument. Brook is a world class fighter and will have more good wins.

[TMT Hassan]

Khan is no 1 welterweight in U.K. Then it's brook, then eggington or w/e. When you compare khans resume to Kells it says it all really.

Olympic Silver medalist at 17
Former unified 140 pound champ
147 silver champ
Commonwealth lightweight champ
Defeated the likes of maidana, collazo, Judah, barrera, kotelnik, salita, malignaggi, alexander, diaz

Whilst kell brook on the other hand
Has won a IBF welterweight title
Has beaten porter (very close and scrappy decision), and the rest of bums and cab drivers like gavin and jojo dan

Says it all really. Eddie Hearn and himself had u believing he was elite. Fooled the public.

[SUBZER0ED]

Lol @ you guys who say Brook isn't special, is a "B" fighter, quitter, ect. He jumped up 2 weight classes to face Golovkin, who has one of the highest KO ratios in the business & is highly regarded by the experts. This, when Canelo was waiting to see if Golovkin could maybe be worn down a bit & weaknesses observed fighting anyone but him. This, when Eubanks, Sr purposely made ridiculous demands to control all aspects of promoting a fight with GGG in order to price his bum son out of it. Kell fought Spence, another highly regarded fighter by the experts. Errol was even projected to be great like Mayweather was, by Mayweather himself. Brook lost to both Golovkin & Spence; not from a terrible ass whipping- he gave both a hard time. But from a broken orbital bone which holds the eye in place. If you get a speck in your eye or a lash, your vision is blurred, it hurts like hell & you can't wait to get it out. Now imagine the very bone structure in your skull that holds your eye in place being fractured! That's got to hurt like a mofo, & your vision has to be seriously fucked. All this, while trying to fight someone who is trying to take your head off. Brook a quitter, not special, a "B" fighter, ect? GTFOH!!

[Jewish-Reptile]

He is no different that all the other guys we hype up.

Spence weak resume
Ggg weak resume
Beterbiev weak resume
Usyk weak resume
Lomanchecko picking up some steam
I could go. Brook is still world class he just dared 2 be great he lost

Usyk is the number one at his weight, Brook has never been the number one at his. Contrasting when you take into account how fights Usyk has had and how many Brook had by the time he narrowly clinched his way past Porter.

Brook hasn't a tenth of the heart Usyk has. He should stick to hanging around gay bars in Grimsby and taking horny sailors back to motels.

[Jewish-Reptile]

Lol @ you guys who say Brook isn't special, is a "B" fighter, quitter, ect. He jumped up 2 weight classes to face Golovkin, who has one of the highest KO ratios in the business & is highly regarded by the experts. This, when Canelo was waiting to see if Golovkin could maybe be worn down a bit & weaknesses observed fighting anyone but him. This, when Eubanks, Sr purposely made ridiculous demands to control all aspects of promoting a fight with GGG in order to price his bum son out of it. Kell fought Spence, another highly regarded fighter by the experts. Errol was even projected to be great like Mayweather was, by Mayweather himself. Brook lost to both Golovkin & Spence; not from a terrible ass whipping- he gave both a hard time. But from a broken orbital bone which holds the eye in place. If you get a speck in your eye or a lash, your vision is blurred, it hurts like hell & you can't wait to get it out. Now imagine the very bone structure in your skull that holds your eye in place being fractured! That's got to hurt like a mofo, & your vision has to be seriously fucked. All this, while trying to fight someone who is trying to take your head off. Brook a quitter, not special, a "B" fighter, ect? GTFOH!!

Dude Broner hurt Porter in the one round he tried, the same Broner who couldn't even remotely hurt Paulie, if Brook was special he'd have shown he could hurt Porter like Broner did, instead he clinched him for 12 rounds like he was hugging his first boyfriend, the ***** fück.

Brook aint special, ok he quit aint no shame he held his own for three rounds and made it competitive for another 4-5 rounds versus Spence. Don't act like he's a hero for facing GGG he wanted a lucrative fight and he paid the price in full getting a thorough beat down and nearly being stopped in one round, dude should never have taken that fight but gullible Brits will pay for anything.

[SUBZER0ED]

Dude Broner hurt Porter in the one round he tried, the same Broner who couldn't even remotely hurt Paulie, if Brook was special he'd have shown he could hurt Porter like Broner did, instead he clinched him for 12 rounds like he was hugging his first boyfriend, the ***** fück.

Brook aint special, ok he quit aint no shame he held his own for three rounds and made it competitive for another 4-5 rounds versus Spence. Don't act like he's a hero for facing GGG he wanted a lucrative fight and he paid the price in full getting a thorough beat down and nearly being stopped in one round, dude should never have taken that fight but gullible Brits will pay for anything.

You say Broner didn't try until the last round against Porter, but why is that? Porter's a wild, brawling rough house mofo and Broner couldn't do shit with him all night until the end, which was not enough. Later, the rarely seen Brook beat the difficult Porter. Paulie couldn't punch because of brittle hands, but he's a cagey, savvy fighter. That's how he lasted as long as he did.

I'm not saying Brook is a superhero, but he sure had the balls to fight one of the most feared men in boxing in Golovkin, while moving up 2 weight classes to do it. While Canelo calls the man up to the ring after KOing glass-jawed and lighter Khan. He talked huge shit in his moment of bravado, then realized, "Oh shit, I'm not ready for this guy yet", and handed Golovkin his belt. I will allow that fighting GGG was a dangerous mistake, which exposed a weakness in his orbital bones. He did at least showcase his ability to give Golovkin a hard time with excellent speed, timing and accuracy. It gave Jacobs the courage to face Golovkin, which in turn gave Canelo courage too. For Kell's trouble, he now probably has titanium steel reinforcing both orbital bones, which may be strong enough to give him another crack at boxing.

[mani1]

I have been saying it for years, Brook is the most carefully managed guy in boxing hadn't fought a puncher in over a decade. As soon as he did he quit before he could get knocked out.

Has an absolute joke of a CV not one guy he beat could beat Julio Diaz in one go. That's right you'all musta forgot.

As for his so called eye injury, if he does not retire im calling bull ****.

[Hype job]

He was good but never elite. Stalled his career for too long wasting his prime years fighting C level guys. 1 good win other than that nothing significant.

[Blender]

I think he lost to Porter. Should've had a few points deducted for holding. Its weird. Because if Porter was British and Brook American, and the fight was in the UK, Porter would've 100% won.

So Brook doesn't really have any good wins at all in his career. Just a roided out tough guy with average skills. He's just a strong dude who overpowered smaller dudes. His actual skills and abilities aren't anything special.

Plus he's a con artist. Spence broke him. He was too cowardly to keep fighting till the end.

[HandsofIron]

Brook is good, his management however was not.