Comments Thread For: Is Lomachenko The Best Pound-for-Pound Fighter in Boxing?

[aboutfkntime]

So using your own logic if I feel a fighter wins fights that they officially loss I can say they are #1 cuz I feel they won the fight. That is absolute crap. Judges decide a fight we dont. Can beat a drum all day but it does not change the result. Either way even with one loss Ward has still done more than Loma and has faced the better competition.

what nonsense

who's P4P list is it, yours or theirs ?

why would you allow others to tell you what you saw ?

you have 2 eyes, right ?

my eyes tell me that if ALL things were equal, and equal in boxing means weight..... the nobody beats Rigo except for maybe Ward and the longer shot Lomachenko

I don't care what others think

[pasawayako]

No question he's the best lb4lb.

[uppercut510]

no hes not but he seems destined for greatness

[BM dnobagaV]

No he's not #1. Resume is too weak. More skill than any other fighter though.

[Shadoww702]

Walters, Russell jr, Martinez, and Salido(l) are much stiffer competition relatively
Versus Jacob's, Brooks(ww),Lemieux

And Golovkin is already planning his next two fights against people he'll be heavily favored to not only beat but beat easily. He should rematch jabcob and remove all doubt and then he can be #1. But he doesn't care about that. He cares about belts.

1. Ward
2. Lomachenko

Walters wasn't even a Champion when he fought Loma. Neither was Salido or Russell Jr.

Lemuix was a Champion. Jacobs #2 was undefeated and ranked higher then anyone Loma has beaten. Brooks was a BS fight but Brooks has MAD skills.

[mathed]

Yeah I think so. I have him number uno right now.

I mean, I realize he doesn't have an impressive number of fights under his belt but the caliber of opponents that he is schooling at such a young point in his professional career more than makes up for the lack of bout volume.

He is not just beating guys but beating them so badly that they feel that they have no recourse but to quit the fight.

[HandsofIron]

He's on the right track.

[whoelsebutjames]

Walters wasn't even a Champion when he fought Loma. Neither was Salido or Russell Jr.

Lemuix was a Champion. Jacobs #2 was undefeated and ranked higher then anyone Loma has beaten. Brooks was a BS fight but Brooks has MAD skills.

While I commend you for coming up with an intelligent answer--I have to disagree with how your weighting your judgement.

They both have thin resumes. But Loma has fought proven fighters who have also fought proven fighters. He also fought fighters that were feared in their own right.

Especially when your giving weight to belts in a thin middleweight division vs a stacked featherweight/superfeather divisions. Well, they were stacked before Loma showed up.

Walters KOd donaire and Darchinyan. Undefeated and was a feared boxer and lost his precious title on scales.

Salido has fought every star that's emerged through those divisions. Juanma, Mikey Garcia, Martinez, Gamboa, Juan Manuel Marquez,

Martinez warred with Salido and fought Mikey.

Russel is extremely talented and was undefeated.

Vs
Jacob's starched quillen and is solid competition.

Lemieux was knocked out by Rubio- who is not even elite level himself. And at the time beat up rosado-who himself was a punching bag at 154(no disrepect he's tough, but comparatively)

And the only undefeated middleweight hes known for toppling is Dominic Wade.

[Shadoww702]

While I commend you for coming up with an intelligent answer--I have to disagree with how your weighting your judgement.

They both have thin resumes. But Loma has fought proven fighters who have also fought proven fighters. He also fought fighters that were feared in their own right.

Especially when your giving weight to belts in a thin middleweight division vs a stacked featherweight/superfeather divisions. Well, they were stacked before Loma showed up.

Walters KOd donaire and Darchinyan. Undefeated and was a feared boxer and lost his precious title on scales.

Salido has fought every star that's emerged through those divisions. Juanma, Mikey Garcia, Martinez, Gamboa, Juan Manuel Marquez,

Martinez warred with Salido and fought Mikey.

Russel is extremely talented and was undefeated.

Vs
Jacob's starched quillen and is solid competition.

Lemieux was knocked out by Rubio- who is not even elite level himself. And at the time beat up rosado-who himself was a punching bag at 154(no disrepect he's tough, but comparatively)

And the only undefeated middleweight hes known for toppling is Dominic Wade.

That we both can agree on. I've also said on MULIPLE occasions the Middleweight Division is DOG sht piled over more dog sht!

When Saunders is a Champion you know your Division SUKS!!! That Artur Akavov almost turned into a Cinderella man over night.

I'm not high on Lemuix at all either. He was TKO'd By Ricky Rubio and lost to CAREER 154lber Alcine. Who lasted a MEASELY 2 minutes and 59 seconds with Angulo...

You take GGG and Jaobs out and it's one of the WORST divisions in history.

[satiev1]

what nonsense

who's P4P list is it, yours or theirs ?

why would you allow others to tell you what you saw ?

you have 2 eyes, right ?

my eyes tell me that if ALL things were equal, and equal in boxing means weight..... the nobody beats Rigo except for maybe Ward and the longer shot Lomachenko

I don't care what others think

The guys gets dropped by bums from japan. Barely beat cordoba in a sd. STOP IT.