whats crawford done thats so amazing...

[Santa_]

Who said he's done anything amazing?

[Rip Chudd]

Just the usual "This black American fighter isn't so great" drivel from bigdramashow. Nothing new to see here folks

[elfag]

weird, the ring doesnt even have manny in the top 10 anymore.

How is he out when he would be a favorite over anyone active today from 140-147, including crawford?

A lot of p4p lists are political as much as they are based on logic. Being a favorite over everyone in two decently stacked divisions, you should be p4p.

Him being out has more to do with him being old and them wanting to make room for newer guys.

[elfag]

Almost no one in the Top 10 P4P is there for their resume.

Inoue - Narvaez.

Yamanaka? Moreno and Darchinyan.

Lomachenko - Russell Jr and Walters.

Golovkin - Murray, Brook, Lemiuex, Rubio.

Gonzalez - Estrada, Cuadras, Arroyo, Yaegashi, Viloria.

Rigondeaux - Donaire, Agbeko.

Crawford - Postol, Gamboa, Burns, Beltran.

Kovalev - Hopkins, Pascal, Chilemba, Cleverly.

Ward - Froch, Kovalev, Kessler, Abraham, Bika, Dawson, Barrera.

As you can see, maybe 3 guys tops are there for their actual resumes.

hmm, canelo has one of the best resumes today....

[Motorcity Cobra]

He hasn't done ****. The top 10 pound for pound list should look like this:

1. GGG
2. Kovalev
3. Loamchenko
4. Klitchko
5. Rocky Balboa
6. Ivan Drago
7. Dude from the movie Southpaw
8. Conor McGregor
9. Ken Masters From Street Fighter
10. Guile From Street Fighter

That looks exactly like my p4p list except I have Usyk in there and not Ken Masters. But overall you have a solid list

[elfag]

Crawford hasnt been amazing per say but he has ben consistent and shown that he is a level above just about everyone he has faced (Gamboa gaveh im his toughes tfight but ended up being too small). He has also carred his skills across 2 weight divisions, kinda the point of p4p. Is he a top 5 p4p, I don't think so (wouldnt argue too much with anyone who would have him as such) but he is certainly top 10 based on his skills transferring across divisions and just how well, theoretically, he would do against other top guys.

crawford is atleast progressing, he should face thurman-garcia winner.

I want to see loma vs mikey garcia.

Rigo is a straight up little ***** for refusing to face loma. He hasnt beaten anyone decent.

[-Kev-]

hmm, canelo has one of the best resumes today....

I noticed immediately that I left him out, but was honestly too lazy to edit my list with him.

TBRB's list is even worse, having Mikey.

Mikey - 2.5 years (or 30 months or 912 days) without a pro fight (January 25, 2014 - July 30, 2016), comes back gets one win - added to TBRB top 10 P4P. You'd think Zlaticanin was ridiculously good, his best win is Ricky Burns.

[g27region]

Its ******..just another one of your i hate black american threads

If you think he hates black americans, why you try to attack so called "eastern euros" in response, instead of just proving his point wrong without bringing up other groups of people (euros)? You don't like these "eastern euros", right?

[MPX309]

That looks exactly like my p4p list except I have Usyk in there and not Ken Masters. But overall you have a solid list

Yeah similar, to mine, but I took Guile out and replaced him with zangief

[Pigeons]

He established the lineage in two weight classes. He took Gamboa and Postol's zeroes.