What are your top three complete, well-rounded fighters of all time

[xrhythmxnxbluesx]

how could you rate oscar above chavez?

you call yourself a boxing fan... pretty boy floyd mayweather... oscar is golden boy... de la hoya is not even in my top twenty...

[+= El Jefe=+]

DLH doesnt compare to Chavez

you cant compare
DLH and Chavez
completely different styles

[Slipx]

you call yourself a boxing fan... pretty boy floyd mayweather... oscar is golden boy... de la hoya is not even in my top twenty...

I read that wrong . but yeah I would hope DLH isn't in your top 3, but I could see him in my top 10 complete fighters. he faced quality opposition, he wasn't too bad of a fighter. he just punked out against tito and bhop, but w/e

[Rockin']

if your talking about "pure" boxing skills you would have to look at Chris Byrd. You may not like him but you can not deny his skill level. And obviously Willie Pep and Pernell Whitaker. Power and skill I say Ray Robinson, Henry Armstrong, Thomas Hearns(not counting his chin)and Michael Spinks at Lightheavy..........Rockin'

[Slipx]

if your talking about "pure" boxing skills you would have to look at Chris Byrd. You may not like him but you can not deny his skill level. And obviously Willie Pep and Pernell Whitaker. Power and skill I say Ray Robinson, Henry Armstrong, Thomas Hearns(not counting his chin)and Michael Spinks at Lightheavy..........Rockin'

by saying complete I mean well rounded in offense,defense, chin, stamina, footwork, reflexes, and handspeed.

edited- yes ,hearns, one of my top five favorites. if he would've had a chin and like a good left hook I think he could've been undefeated, but the right hand was enough to make him rich at least.

[oldgringo]

Ali was very close to being a complete fighter.

MArvin Hagler was pretty close to being a complete fighter early in his career.

Of course Ray Robinson.

[Tha Greatest]

ya

THE THREE DETROIT BOXERS!!!

1. JOE LOUIS!
2. "Sugar" Ray Robinson!
3. Thomas "The Hitman" Hearns

i will be up there in a few years......just wait

[Colonel Jones]

1) Duran
2) Duran
3) Duran

[TheGreat1]

Holmes
JCC
Hagler/Duran

[hitterwitter]

Indeed RJJ was a class act during his prime, but I'd have to say his defense left much to be desired...

If RJJ was such a class act he would never have ducked Steve Collins, Collins was the best Super Middleweight at the time and RJJ new he couldn't beat him. Remember when collins got in the ring after one of RJJ fights and called him out and he just avoided him.

RJJ lost all my respect after this, it was the fight every boxing fan wanted to see and it didn't happen because of one person RJJ, you cant blame the brit this time for ducking a big fight.