Will Canelo Be ATG If He Stops Golovkin??

[Canelo and GGG]

Heck no.

Washed up Mosley

Debatable win vs Lara(I had it a draw as neither did enough to win)

Trout was a decent win

Cotto was ok as well

That is not a hall of fame resume

Can you Tell me best micky Ward wins, thats right his Hofer ,Canelo wins and popularity gives him HoF if he retire now LMAO

[Bardock]

This is when I know people are plain liars.

Did you even watch GGG v Macklin and Geale?

Geale? lol he chose not to get up. Macklin was due to a body shot. Both neither impressive knockouts. You're acting like he's putting top 10 opponents to sleep. That is what you would call legitimate KO power.

[Larry the boss]

no..............

[Larry the boss]

I dunno about ATG but if he actually stops GGG, puts on a beating, takes him to the cleaners etc etc, then it would be THE win of the decade so far, better than JMM stopping Pacquiao cold, better than Mayweather pitty pattying his way to victory and better than Furys best/worst Ali impression over Wlad.

No way in hell...lol

[soul_survivor]

Geale? lol he chose not to get up. Macklin was due to a body shot. Both neither impressive knockouts. You're acting like he's putting top 10 opponents to sleep. That is what you would call legitimate KO power.

Lol your posting an image of a body punch KO and yet claim Macklins isn't an example because it was a body shot?

you're a clown.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

No but it does make him a lock for the hall of fame..

He could still be an atg depending on his longevity and other future victories in the future, I just don't think you can bestow it on him for only one fight.

[Bardock]

Lol your posting an image of a body punch KO and yet claim Macklins isn't an example because it was a body shot?

you're a clown.

Never said it wasn't an example. Just not a top 10 guy. Show me Golovkin 1 punching KO'ing guys who are worth a damn. Geale who was KO'd by Cotto not really impressive.

[soul_survivor]

No way in hell...lol

why not?

Marquez beat Pacquiao for size, he was always taller, think he had a longer reach too. Plus it was largely accepted that JMM had beaten him the last time Pac had faced him at welterweight. Plus it was widely acknowledged by the time that Pacquiao was no longer as fearsome.

it's a great win and currently the best win of this decade but if Canelo can beat a guy who is bigger, longer, hits harder and breaks bones by KO, especially a dominant KO, then I don't see how it's not a bigger or better win.

I know GGG isn't Pacquiao but dimensions are important. The 3 best wins of the decade so far have to be:

JMM over Pac
Fury over Wlad
May over Pac

At the very least, a KO of GGG sends Canelo over the bottom 2.

[soul_survivor]

Never said it wasn't an example. Just not a top 10 guy. Show me Golovkin 1 punching KO'ing guys who are worth a damn. Geale who was KO'd by Cotto not really impressive.

"Geale? lol he chose not to get up. Macklin was due to a body shot."

You word for word. That's you trying to discount a one punch KO by claiming it was to the body as a neg. Then you post a pic of another body punch KO. But let's accept you didn't mention it that way.

What makes you say Geale wasn't a top 10 guy? He was a 2 time middleweight champ and was ranked as top 10 by just about everyone in the sport at 160. The same goes for Macklin and Murray. Heck, even Stevenson (which I thought was bs). The only top 10 legit guy GGG didn't get a hold of was Barker and Sturm. Barker was injured and Sturm ran.

Plus, you're going to mention quality and then post a KO of Liam ****ing Smith?

Like I said, you're a clown, a liar and in all honesty, not worth my time.

[hugh grant]

If nelo beats GGG it wont make him an atg. But if nelo continues to win against oppiknents not quite as good as ggg for the remainder of hius career, with a few more losses, he could end up as one.
With GGG his signature win and best win. The one people point to in making a case for nelo being one.
Basically GGG could be below best ever win. Most likely will be. I doubt nelo will beat anyone better