Is The Ring Magazine P4P Top 10 Rankings a Joke?

[1hourRun]

Manny pac should still be on p4p lists...

Wlad hasn't fought in over a year and last time out he got cleanly outboxed by fury.. Got no problem with people dropping him from the rankings...

Roman shouldn't be #1, ggg isn't a top 3

Ward
Kovolev
Roman
Rigo
Manny
Golovkin
Crawford
Frampton
Canelo
Lomachenko

In my personal opinion

You said Wlad hasnt fought in a year ( note he was stood up by Fury ) but you got Ward as your number #1. after years of inactivity to only fight Paul Smith, Barrera and Brand?

[i got the keys]

Im still waiting on your list...could it be the fact that you have to include : Crawford,Ward, and maybe even Rigo is keeping from presenting your row of killers?

I found his list.

1.GGG
2.Triple G
3.Triplet G
4.Golovkin
5.Gennady
6.Gennadyevich
7.Gennadyevich Golovkin
8.GG+G=GGG
9.G...G....G?
10. Joe Calzaghe

[Madison Boxing]

Im still waiting on your list...could it be the fact that you have to include : Crawford,Ward, and maybe even Rigo is keeping from presenting your row of killers?

ggg
kovalev
pacquiao
crawford
frampton
klitschko
bradley
lomachenko
canelo
rigondeaux

quick p4p list, havent put huge amount of thought into it other than the top 5

[Madison Boxing]

I found his list.

1.GGG
2.Triple G
3.Triplet G
4.Golovkin
5.Gennady
6.Gennadyevich
7.Gennadyevich Golovkin
8.GG+G=GGG
9.G...G....G?
10. Joe Calzaghe

hahaha, fair enough that did make me laugh

[1hourRun]

I found his list.

1.GGG
2.Triple G
3.Triplet G
4.Golovkin
5.Gennady
6.Gennadyevich
7.Gennadyevich Golovkin
8.GG+G=GGG
9.G...G....G?
10. Joe Calzaghe

hahaha! Kell Brook, Liam Smith, Joshua, Lee Selby,Haskins, RRRRRRRRRRRRRicky Burns tho!

[Citizen Koba]

Look at my sig. That's the nsb voted pfp list

It actually worked out pretty well that didn't it? No massive controversy. I'm betting most of us would tweak a few positions up and down, but there's nothing outrageous going on there.

[1hourRun]

ggg
kovalev
pacquiao
crawford
frampton
klitschko
bradley
lomachenko
canelo
rigondeaux

quick p4p list, havent put huge amount of thought into it other than the top 5

I see Golovkin over multiweight unified lineal champions with HOF fighters in their resume....how many times has GGG been lineal? how many elite fighters has he beat? who in his resume is going into the HOF? to be honest Kovalev should be above Golovkin in your list if you wanted to pretend to be serious...even Tyson Fury could of made a better case.

[Madison Boxing]

I see Golovkin over multiweight unified lineal champions with HOF fighters in their resume....how many times has GGG been lineal? how many elite fighters has he beat? who in his resume is going into the HOF? to be honest Kovalev should be above Golovkin in your list if you wanted to pretend to be serious...even Tyson Fury could of made a better case.

fury would be on there but not counting him as active fighter. if (when) kovalev smashes ward he'll be number 1 most likely

[Citizen Koba]

aha i can assure you im not, 6 ft 3. I say the midget shouldnt be top, because theres no real interest in them divisions, and the sad truth of it is that they are freaks of nature. WHat next, if there was a dwarf who was 100-0 would you put him top of p4p list?

Yeah. I'm not quite sure you get what P4P is. What it ain't - or at least shouldn't be - is a popularity contest, however.

[daggum]

sam eggington should be getting votes