Who is better: Paul Smith/Barrera or David Lemieux/Murray/Macklin/Geale

[therealpugilist]

Not rocket science = fights from a tourny half a decade ago have no bearing on todays landscape.

......o...k


so no elite wins at all= not top ten p4p
.....glad we could clear that up

[Medinabcheatin]

Triple Chicken the biggest joke in boxing. His fans ain't know ish bout boxing, they just like him cause he white.. YDKSAB!!

[Chrismart]

Slightly off topic maybe, but focusing in on Murray and Smith... Smith isn't as good as Murray.

I'm a Smith fan, have been for years. He's from my neck of the woods and i've travelled around to watch him since his early days. But Murray was better.

[Kagami Taiga]

Slightly off topic maybe, but focusing in on Murray and Smith... Smith isn't as good as Murray.

I'm a Smith fan, have been for years. He's from my neck of the woods and i've travelled around to watch him since his early days. But Murray was better.

Murray isnt very good either. He got by because of his strength, size and defense. But he's not even as good as George Groves at 168. That says a lot.

[Beercules]

Triple Chicken the biggest joke in boxing. His fans ain't know ish bout boxing, they just like him cause he white.. YDKSAB!!

that boy doesn't have the correct pigment

[Beercules]

Murray isnt very good either. He got by because of his strength, size and defense. But he's not even as good as George Groves at 168. That says a lot.

Murray should've beaten Martinez.

[Vasyl’s dad]

......o...k


so no elite wins at all= not top ten p4p
.....glad we could clear that up

Beating the best fighters in your division that aren't afraid to lose>>>>dragging up smaller and old fighter up to catchweights in the lightheavyweight division. Btw, your issue should be with espn. They have GGG at #2 like they have Floyd as the best fighter of this era.

[Chrismart]

Murray should've beaten Martinez.

Yeah mate, i felt for him in that one. He was robbed.

[Beercules]

Yeah mate, i felt for him in that one. He was robbed.

Yeah that was terrible. It had to be in Argentina

[soul_survivor]

Barrera is the best guy on that entire list. Lemieux and Geale aren't as skilled, nowhere near. They've been around longer yet Barrera is clearly the better talent.

Is this a GGG vs Ward thread ? If it is Ward handles GGG with ease, deal with it and move on with your life instead of dressing threads up.

Why is Barrera better?

Please do explain.