Where does Joe Calzaghe stand in your P4P all time list?

[hugh grant]

That was funny. Got any other good jokes?

Jc is unbeaten, just like floyd and he beat arguably someone who is greater than floyd in bh in America. He beat Kessler who beat froch so of course he is better than frock as he would beat Froch in fantasy fight

[Johnny Rubber]

An awful lot of salt in this thread. JC really messed with peoples perception of other fighters didn't he!

If, but, prime blah blah Basing opinion on fights that never happened will always be laughable at best.

Lacey was schooled, Jones was given a "vag-eye-na" and Hopkins was out-boxed, which no amount of retrospect will change.

[LetOutTheCage]

Jc is unbeaten, just like floyd and he beat arguably someone who is greater than floyd in bh in America. He beat Kessler who beat froch so of course he is better than frock as he would beat Froch in fantasy fight

He would beat Froch because Froch is a very limited boxer, heavy handed and a great chin but slow both in his legs and his hand speed. He is also very easy to hit so unless you think Froch would knock out Calzaghe i'm not sure what other way he would beat Calzaghe? He certainly wouldn't be able to out-work him.

[b00g13man]

He would beat Froch because Froch is a very limited boxer, heavy handed and a great chin but slow both in his legs and his hand speed. He is also very easy to hit so unless you think Froch would knock out Calzaghe i'm not sure what other way he would beat Calzaghe? He certainly wouldn't be able to out-work him.

How many times have we said that in the past? He kept finding a way to win.

[LetOutTheCage]

How many times have we said that in the past? He kept finding a way to win.

I know he struggles with opponents with fast hands, that move a lot and that can outwork him. Ward, Direll and Taylor were all fights he struggled in. The only one he legitimately won was the Taylor one and that's because Taylor gassed and made a mistake.

Question to you then B00g13. Do you think a prime Froch would have beaten a prime Calzaghe? and if so how would he have won?

[b00g13man]

I know he struggles with opponents with fast hands, that move a lot and that can outwork him. Ward, Direll and Taylor were all fights he struggled in. The only one he legitimately won was the Taylor one and that's because Taylor gassed and made a mistake.

Question to you then B00g13. Do you think a prime Froch would have beaten a prime Calzaghe? and if so how would he have won?

Probably not, but we'll never know for sure now. Stop hating tabouleh!!!

[K-Nan]

lets see he beat ATG Hopkins and ATG Jones, and RUINED LACY CAREER

so I have him slightly above Hopkins and Jones and ahead of ward in the grand scheme of things today.

Lol..... Nice bait.

Anyways, his best win was over a prime Kessler. Followed by beating the older version of B-Hop. The Roy Jones fight was a sham and should never have been made.

[K-Nan]

James Toney is as real a hitta as it gets but let's not go crazy. Joe would've flatlined his ass within 6.

A) Calzaghe was known to slap with his punches. He was never a KO puncher.

B) James Toney has quite arguable a top 5 all time chin

C) Idk if u just never watched either guy or if you're trolling

[Outworn]

Definitely higher than Roy and Nard cos he beat them both and retired undefeated.

[Zaroku]

I believe Froch would have knocked him out. Grove too!