Joe Louis's Top 5 Wins

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ray Corso
    Undisputed Champion
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Jan 2012
    • 7988
    • 610
    • 0
    • 21,253

    #31
    Here's something that's never mentioned when speaking of Joe Louis. He lost 4 full years of prime age because of WW2.
    When evaluating a skill level it helps to have a wide variety of opponents but when you don't you actually need to know techniques and then add in desire and attitude! If you NEED to have opponents to make a judgement chances are your limited when it comes to knowledge of the sport.
    Louis at 6'2" 200lbs would easily fight at 215-220 if projected to the 2000 era.
    Back then heavyweights trained down to lighter weight because of the length of rounds and over all more activity.
    If you watch Louis you can actually see boxing evolve as he matures!
    He had Mr. Blackburn as his mentor and every trainer today is still using Mr. Blackburns techniques, at least the good ones do.

    There were alot of fighters through the 30's into the 50's that were outstanding boxers in technique and conditioning. Benny Leonard was fantastic, Willie Pep remains one the greatest pure boxer who ever lived. Billy Conn and Tunney were outstanding boxers along with Louis.
    Sugar Ray Robinson remains TBE and p4p King, no one comes close!
    The reason Wlad and men like Fury are dominate today is because there are NO outstanding talents in the sport right now! Wilder is a game young man but his technique suffers, Fury has his size to help him but technique wise he's sloppy and has no right hand to speak of. Joe Louis had a weak era but wiped it clean but he had talent if you knew techniques you could see it on film. Wlad has a weak era also but he's a one/two stand tall and lean away and hold guy. Not much dimension and a shaky chin too!
    Heres a few good fighters that I'm sure are not very well known who fought Louis;
    Max Baer
    Charley Retzloff
    Max Schmeling
    Bob Pastor
    John Henry Lewis
    Buddy Baer--(who was the big guy then 6'6" 240lbs)
    Billy Conn
    Lou Nova
    past Louis prime were a few good ones also;
    Joe Walcott
    Ezzard Charles
    Lee Savold
    Jimmy Bivens

    Back then records could be deceiving when you had newspaper decisions, traveling into an opponents turf and both were contenders. Different times brought about different circumstances. There was a "waiting order" for contenders and it often meant dropping a decision or two. Not throwing the fight just getting the short end if it went the distance.

    The fact that anyone could think that Wlad has more technical ability or knowledge over Louis is a sad state of affairs for boxing fans!

    Ray

    Comment

    • TheBoxingXpert
      Undisputed Champion
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Mar 2016
      • 1544
      • 101
      • 0
      • 8,170

      #32
      Originally posted by Ray Corso
      Here's something that's never mentioned when speaking of Joe Louis. He lost 4 full years of prime age because of WW2.
      When evaluating a skill level it helps to have a wide variety of opponents but when you don't you actually need to know techniques and then add in desire and attitude! If you NEED to have opponents to make a judgement chances are your limited when it comes to knowledge of the sport.
      Louis at 6'2" 200lbs would easily fight at 215-220 if projected to the 2000 era.
      Back then heavyweights trained down to lighter weight because of the length of rounds and over all more activity.
      If you watch Louis you can actually see boxing evolve as he matures!
      He had Mr. Blackburn as his mentor and every trainer today is still using Mr. Blackburns techniques, at least the good ones do.

      There were alot of fighters through the 30's into the 50's that were outstanding boxers in technique and conditioning. Benny Leonard was fantastic, Willie Pep remains one the greatest pure boxer who ever lived. Billy Conn and Tunney were outstanding boxers along with Louis.
      Sugar Ray Robinson remains TBE and p4p King, no one comes close!
      The reason Wlad and men like Fury are dominate today is because there are NO outstanding talents in the sport right now! Wilder is a game young man but his technique suffers, Fury has his size to help him but technique wise he's sloppy and has no right hand to speak of. Joe Louis had a weak era but wiped it clean but he had talent if you knew techniques you could see it on film. Wlad has a weak era also but he's a one/two stand tall and lean away and hold guy. Not much dimension and a shaky chin too!
      Heres a few good fighters that I'm sure are not very well known who fought Louis;
      Max Baer
      Charley Retzloff
      Max Schmeling
      Bob Pastor
      John Henry Lewis
      Buddy Baer--(who was the big guy then 6'6" 240lbs)
      Billy Conn
      Lou Nova
      past Louis prime were a few good ones also;
      Joe Walcott
      Ezzard Charles
      Lee Savold
      Jimmy Bivens

      Back then records could be deceiving when you had newspaper decisions, traveling into an opponents turf and both were contenders. Different times brought about different circumstances. There was a "waiting order" for contenders and it often meant dropping a decision or two. Not throwing the fight just getting the short end if it went the distance.

      The fact that anyone could think that Wlad has more technical ability or knowledge over Louis is a sad state of affairs for boxing fans!

      Ray
      Max Baer had just lost to a journeyman, Max Schmeling had gotten knocked out by bums over and over again and the other guys are mostly no better than the average bums knocked out by Deontay Wilder.

      The heavyweight era of today is far better than the era of Joe Louis. Bigger guys with far better resumes. Joe Louis's opponents had achieved nothing. The big chance Joe Louis had to get a respectable win was against Marciano, but sadly, he was too shot to beat him at that time...

      Comment

      • soul_survivor
        LOL @ Ali-Holmes
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • Jun 2013
        • 18949
        • 623
        • 473
        • 65,236

        #33
        Louis had a resume which ranged from bad to mediocre.

        His top 5 wins are:

        Conn
        Jersey Joe
        Braddock
        Schmeling
        Sharkey/Gelanto/ I dunno I'm stuck

        If I'm not mistaken, he never beat an ATG heavyweight or even one approaching exceptional quality. It was a piss poor division at the time, so not entirely his fault.

        Having said, much like Holmes or Wlad, he did often dominate these guys and proved he was a step or two ahead. The down side is, he had his ass handed to him by a small fighter like Conn, who took full advantage of Louis dragging feet and hunched over style.

        It's a tough one.

        Comment

        • TheBoxingXpert
          Undisputed Champion
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Mar 2016
          • 1544
          • 101
          • 0
          • 8,170

          #34
          Originally posted by soul_survivor
          Louis had a resume which ranged from bad to mediocre.

          His top 5 wins are:

          Conn
          Jersey Joe
          Braddock
          Schmeling
          Sharkey/Gelanto/ I dunno I'm stuck

          If I'm not mistaken, he never beat an ATG heavyweight or even one approaching exceptional quality. It was a piss poor division at the time, so not entirely his fault.

          Having said, much like Holmes or Wlad, he did often dominate these guys and proved he was a step or two ahead. The down side is, he had his ass handed to him by a small fighter like Conn, who took full advantage of Louis dragging feet and hunched over style.

          It's a tough one.
          Imagine how Wilder would be worshipped today if he had fought in Louis' era. He would have KOed all of Louis' opponents, lol, there were no David Hayes or Tyson Furys or Klitschkos to stop him back then. But yeah, Louis was a step ahead of his time, it was just a very bad time.
          Last edited by TheBoxingXpert; 03-31-2016, 04:28 AM.

          Comment

          • soul_survivor
            LOL @ Ali-Holmes
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • Jun 2013
            • 18949
            • 623
            • 473
            • 65,236

            #35
            Originally posted by TheBoxingXpert
            Imagine how Wilder would be worshipped today if he had fought in Louis' era. He would have KOed all of Louis' opponents, lol, there were no David Hayes or Tyson Furys or Klitschkos to stop him back then. But yeah, Louis was a step ahead of his time, it was just a very bad time.
            LOL, why you rating Wilder so highly? The guys gone so many rounds with 2 journeymen, while holding one of the most prestigious belts out there. Just because I'm saying Louis fought in a weak era and against a whole host of bums, doesn't mean I'm one of those idiots who think fighters are better now because they weigh more.

            Comment

            • TheBoxingXpert
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Mar 2016
              • 1544
              • 101
              • 0
              • 8,170

              #36
              Originally posted by soul_survivor
              LOL, why you rating Wilder so highly? The guys gone so many rounds with 2 journeymen, while holding one of the most prestigious belts out there. Just because I'm saying Louis fought in a weak era and against a whole host of bums, doesn't mean I'm one of those idiots who think fighters are better now because they weigh more.
              Wilder would probably lose to both Wladimir, Fury, Joshua, Martin and Ortiz.

              I'm not ranking Wilder highly. I'm saying he would KO all of Louis' horrible opponents.

              Comment

              • deathofaclown
                Undisputed Champion
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Apr 2015
                • 16322
                • 3,919
                • 50
                • 98,604

                #37
                Who cares?

                He was a flat footed basic fighter from about 70 years ago. No fighter from then, even Louis could complete today.

                Honestly, he wouldn't even last a round with Dillian Whyte or someone like Dominic Guinn.

                Comment

                • TheBoxingXpert
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Mar 2016
                  • 1544
                  • 101
                  • 0
                  • 8,170

                  #38
                  Originally posted by deathofaclown
                  Who cares?

                  He was a flat footed basic fighter from about 70 years ago. No fighter from then, even Louis could complete today.

                  Honestly, he wouldn't even last a round with Dillian Whyte or someone like Dominic Guinn.
                  I see him lasting at least 4 rounds against Whyte.

                  Comment

                  • Ray Corso
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Jan 2012
                    • 7988
                    • 610
                    • 0
                    • 21,253

                    #39
                    .."Max Schmeling had gotten knocked out by bums over and over again "


                    What "bums" KO'd Max prior to meeting Louis in their first fight or second fight?

                    You seem to be pretty sure what and who your talking about but I have a feeling your looking at names on boxrec and have no clue who these men were.

                    Ray

                    Comment

                    • TheBoxingXpert
                      Undisputed Champion
                      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                      • Mar 2016
                      • 1544
                      • 101
                      • 0
                      • 8,170

                      #40
                      Originally posted by Ray Corso
                      .."Max Schmeling had gotten knocked out by bums over and over again "


                      What "bums" KO'd Max prior to meeting Louis in their first fight or second fight?

                      You seem to be pretty sure what and who your talking about but I have a feeling your looking at names on boxrec and have no clue who these men were.

                      Ray
                      Max Dieckman, with an impressive record of 0-0, KOed Max.
                      Larry Gains, with an impressive record of 20-7, KOed Max.
                      Gipsy Daniels, with an impressive record of 77-22, KOed Max.

                      He also got KOed by Louis and Baer, but those are more acceptable KO losses.

                      Besides that, he often lost point decisions to journeymen.

                      He did have 2 fairly respectable wins, though. He defeated Louis in their first fight and he did beat Young Stribling.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP