Danny Garcia vs Kell Brook, who takes it?

[NaijaD]

khanturds voting for Garcia

A more pathetic group of fans don't exist.

The fact that Khan still has such loyal fans is puzzling to me, all talk and no risks taken.

Garcia's only advantage in this match up is chin and toughness, that is not enough and his power at 147 seems very average, his only claim to being a power puncher is knocking Khan out lool.

I see this as an easy fight for Brook, honestly Carson Jones would probably give Danny Garcia absolute hell at 147.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Broner is a stationary target, he doesnt move, yet Porter still lost and got hurt badly...

Kell clinched his way to a close win...

Porter isnt a good boxer, short arms, no rhythm, no technique..all he does is bum rush his opponents.

Alexander had nothing to keep a guy like Porter off and Malignaggi was washed up..also i believe Porter was roided to his gills in these fights

Porter lost to Julio Diaz, i don't care if it was a draw, he lost. That should tell you how good of a boxer he really is. Khan struggled with Diaz, but he was coming off a devastating loss, new trainer, he fought nervous, but got the win.

Danny hits a lot harder than Scheneko..and chin for chin, Danny has been in the ring with the bigger puncher and never so much as flinched

Danny Ko's Brook, mid rounds..he'll take all of Brooks heavy shots, just to get one of his own off.

Porter lost to Broner? the level of desperation by Khan fans to downplay Brook gets funnier by the week.

Brook outboxed him with ease, controlled the fight and won easily. Facts.

If the fight actually gets made you'll have new excuses for when Brook beats him up. 'Too small for 147', 'he had the flu'...something along those lines.

[FrankieBruno]

Garcia has never fought someone of the caliber of Kell Brook. I can't see how he's ever going to beat Brook.

We never know until they fight, but as a Brook fan that's one of the fights I'm least worried about.

Ps. Funny you mention Porter punching with his eyes closed. But who started the no-look-left-hook?

Maybe ask Khan.

Garcia times his hook with perfection, he might throw it with his eyes closed, but he sets it up beautifully with his eyes open.

Porter literally fights with his eyes closed, the guy is such a crap boxer, small trex arms.

[FrankieBruno]

Porter lost to Broner? the level of desperation by Khan fans to downplay Brook gets funnier by the week.

Brook outboxed him with ease, controlled the fight and won easily. Facts.

If the fight actually gets made you'll have new excuses for when Brook beats him up. 'Too small for 147', 'he had the flu'...something along those lines.

imo he did

If Brook won the figth with ease why did his own stablemate Ryan Rhodes have it draw?

Why did the commentators give it to Porter


Why did a boxing historian like Tyson Fury say Porter won?

[gmc_rfc_06]

imo he did

If Brook won the figth with ease why did his own stablemate Ryan Rhodes have it draw?

Why did the commentators give it to Porter


Why did a boxing historian like Tyson Fury say Porter won?

Media scores and press row scores:

Brook: 49 media scores, 80%
Porter: 9 media scores, 15%
Draw: 3 media scores, 5%

Boxing media scorecards from ringside and TV:

Tris Dixon (BoxingNewsED) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Boxing Guru : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Brian Campbell (ESPN) : 117-111 Brook (TV)

Jim Watt (Sky TV) : 115-114 Porter (Ringside)

Steve Adams Jnr (Ringnews24) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Daniel Vano (***************) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

The QueensBerry Rules : 117-111 Brook (TV)

The Title Fight : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Phil D Jay (World Boxing News) : 116-113 Brook (TV)

Victor M Salazar (ThaBoxingVoice) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Steve Kim (UCN Live) : 115-113 Brook (Ringside)

Paul Webb (FirstClassBoxing) : 115-114 Brook (TV)

Scott Christ (BadLeftHook) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Adam Abramowitz (SaturNightBoxing) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Adam Canavan (BoxingMadMagazine) : 114-114 Draw (TV)

Tommy Allan (************) : 114-114 Draw (TV)

Jake Donovan (BoxingScene) : 117-111 Brook (TV)

Boxing Socialist : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Danny Winterbottom (BoxingNews) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Leave It In The Ring Radio : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Kevin McRae (Bleacher Report) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

IEdit Boxing : 115-113 Porter (TV)

AllAboutBoxing : 117-112 Brook (TV)

Rich Marotta (KFIAM Radio) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Lyle Fitzsimmons (BoxingScene) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Cliff Rold (BoxingScene) : 117-112 Brook (TV)

Shaun Brown (BoxingScene) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Kurt Ward (************) : 116-112 Porter (TV)

Fighters Rated : 117-111 Brook (TV)

Alex Morris (************) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Andy Clarke (BoxNation TV) : 115-113 Porter (TV)

Dan Rafael (ESPN) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

John A MacDonald (Livefight) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Kasim Aslam (Global Boxing) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Bob Velin (USA Today) : 114-114 Draw (TV)

Boxrec News : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Sam Sheppard (QueensBerryRules) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

KO Radio : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Ciaran Gibbons (Freelance) : 117-113 Porter (TV)

Iconic Boxing : 115-114 Brook (TV)

Ryan Bivins (SweetBoxing) : 117-111 Brook (TV)

Lem Sattersfield (Ring Magazine) : 117-112 Brook (TV)

Boxing Philosopher : 116-112 Porter (TV)

Instant Boxing : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Johnathan Mitrosky (LaceUpBoxing) : 116-112 Porter (TV)

The TKO Network : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Associated Press : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Doug Fischer (Ring Magazine) : 115-113 Brook (Ringside)

Asian Boxing : 116-113 Brook (TV)

Corey Quincy (Freelance) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

John Hoolan (Freelance) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

John Evans (Livefight) : 115-114 Porter (TV)

Ciaran Shanks (Irvine Times) : 115-113 Porter (TV)

Rob Day (Ringnews24) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Robert Palmer (***************) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Nigel Collins (ESPN FNFs) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

V2 Boxing : 115-114 Brook (TV)

Ray Markarian (LA Times) : 115-113 Brook (TV)

Andy Paterson (************) : 116-113 Brook (TV)

Tom Gray (Ring Magazine) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

Graham Houston (Boxing Monthly) : 116-112 Brook (TV)

-----------

It was clear cut, wasn't even a close fight.

[FrankieBruno]

I dont care what the media scores say, most of those cards look very close...


The only opinion that matters is Tyson Fury's..if he says Porter won, its good by me

[BigAlexSand]

Broner is a stationary target, he doesnt move, yet Porter still lost IMO and got hurt badly...

Kell clinched his way to a close win...

Porter isnt a good boxer, short arms, no rhythm, no technique..all he does is bum rush his opponents.

Alexander had nothing to keep a guy like Porter off and Malignaggi was washed up..also i believe Porter was roided to his gills in these fights

Porter lost to Julio Diaz, i don't care if it was a draw, he lost. That should tell you how good of a boxer he really is. Khan struggled with Diaz, but he was coming off a devastating loss, new trainer, he fought nervous, but got the win.

Danny hits a lot harder than Scheneko..and chin for chin, Danny has been in the ring with the bigger puncher and never so much as flinched

Danny Ko's Brook, mid rounds..he'll take all of Brooks heavy shots, just to get one of his own off.

The fact you think Broner won the fight against Porter by literally throwing 0 punchs till the 12, is down right hysterical. Porter would scare the ****** out of Khan, and most likely KO Khan. Brook handled Porters pressure perfectly.

Saying this, Brook would be able to bully and outbox Garcia relatively easily.

[BigAlexSand]

I dont care what the media scores say, most of those cards look very close...


The only opinion that matters is Tyson Fury's..if he says Porter won, its good by me

Are you f***ing kidding me right now? Now that is the biggest fanboy statement of all time!!!! Holy Sh**...

Mike Tyson said it so it must be true... Boxing is dead.
Tyson Fury said it so it must be true... Hell is here because of too many Gays.
Floyd Mayweather said it so it must be true... He is the best ever and Guerrero was winning the fight against Garcia.

[Box-Office]

I voted points, but damn we might see a KO.

[FrankieBruno]

The fact you think Broner won the fight against Porter by literally throwing 0 punchs till the 12, is down right hysterical. Porter would scare the ****** out of Khan, and most likely KO Khan. Brook handled Porters pressure perfectly.

Saying this, Brook would be able to bully and outbox Garcia relatively easily.

Porter is a extremely easy fight for Khan, i've said it on here countless times

Small, short arms, below average power, no technique.

Khan will jab and clinch his way to a win...and make it look so easy, unlike Brook

If Porter were taller and had a longer reach i could see him causing problems for Khan.