Danny Garcia vs Kell Brook, who takes it?

[M Bison]

Cling on to whatever you can.

Garcia himself lost clearly to Herrera, had a toss-up with Peterson, had a very tough night with a 35 year old Judah...

Hopefully this fight gets made, but it will be one-sided.

Agreed, easy work for Amir Khan mate.

[gmc_rfc_06]

Agreed, easy work for Amir Khan mate.

As easy as last time;

[Hype job]

Did Garcia prove himself the best of the welterweight division by beating Malignaggi and Guerrero? Hmm...

We obviously have different views on who's the top WWs in the world.

Seems like people agree with me huh? Thread backfire.

Brook would beat Garcia with ease. Too big, too strong and too accurate.

Put him in there with the likes of Pacquiao, Bradley, Thurman, Khan or Porter again and we'd see solid 50/50 fights in some cases.

Not against Garcia.

People get emotional when it comes to Garcia, their personal disdain for him bypasses any potential for an objective analysis of his talents.

Brook either stops him or takes a wide decision (117-111 range).

He's simply the better fighter. Sharper puncher, more skilled, more variation, faster, stronger, bigger....

Brook isn't faster than Garcia, he isn't fast at all. What you guys gloss over is that he has only beaten one top fighter in his whole career, you're judging his abilities by analysing him against C and D level opposition.

Danny Garcia was facing Brook's level of opponents when he was a 22yr old novice.

[////]

brook is some sort of mythical being who never does anything and half his fans have never even watched him box but he's 9999-0 in fantasy matchups, usually beginning with the sentence "From what I've heard..."

garcia is an unlikeable fighter but has a long list of solid wins

you know which one ill bet on

[Hype job]

Garcia has never fought someone of the caliber of Kell Brook. I can't see how he's ever going to beat Brook.

We never know until they fight, but as a Brook fan that's one of the fights I'm least worried about.

Ps. Funny you mention Porter punching with his eyes closed. But who started the no-look-left-hook?

Maybe ask Khan.

What is this calibre? What has this guy ever proven? Aside from overrated Porter who has he beaten?

I thought Matthysse was the fighter with the most unwarranted hype I've ever seen but Brook has him beat on this by a country mile.

[Dr Rumack]

Brook I think. Stylistic nightmare for Danny.

[gmc_rfc_06]

People get emotional when it comes to Garcia, their personal disdain for him bypasses any potential for an objective analysis of his talents.


Brook isn't faster than Garcia, he isn't fast at all. What you guys gloss over is that he has only beaten one top fighter in his whole career, you're judging his abilities by analysing him against C and D level opposition.

Danny Garcia was facing Brook's level of opponents when he was a 22yr old novice.

Brook is far faster than Garcia, it's not even close. He's also got better timing, better accuracy and sharper punches.

It won't even be close if they fight. Brook will outbox him with complete ease and might even stop him.

[Chrismart]

I see a wide points win for Brook. May even get the late stoppage.

[Hype job]

Brook is far faster than Garcia, it's not even close. He's also got better timing, better accuracy and sharper punches.

It won't even be close if they fight. Brook will outbox him with complete ease and might even stop him.

What sheer nonsense, Brook has mediocre speed, his timing is good but Garcia is recognized as being amongst the very best in terms of timing, and he's timed opponents levels above the garbage Crook has faced.

Crook is Matthysse 2.0, actually he's even more overhyped than Matthysse, who destroyed better opponents than Crook.

[No Tomorrow]

Brook by a disputed SD