The Reason Muhammad Ali Is Better Than Floyd Mayweather

[Tony Trick-Pony]

The Real Reason Why Deontay Wilder is Better Than Sugar Ray Robinson


Because he couldn't beat Deontay Wilder in a boxing match, especially a prime Wilder. It's just that simple.

In my opinion, to be the 'best' of anything concerning fighting, you have to be able to defeat EVERYBODY, no matter what their size, weight, or strength is. Imagine someone walking around on the street saying that they were the greatest fighter in the world or the baddest person in the world. You would naturally interpret them as meaning that they could beat anyone and everyone that they came across. If they were to then say that "No, I mean I'm the greatest fighter or the baddest person in the world when fighting guys that are only my same size and weight", you would . Because that's not truly being the best fighter in the world then, is it?

Wilder is a HEAVYWEIGHT. So we know he can stand toe to toe with smaller boxers as well as the big ones. Can Robinson, at his size, defeat Deontay Wilder, whether it be the 2000's Wilder or the 2020's Wilder? If not, then how can be 'better'?

Actually, I can see Robinson taking Wilder.

[Slip Stream]

The Reason Jack Johnson Is Better Than Floyd Mayweather

Because he couldn't beat Jack Johnson in a boxing match, especially a prime Johnson. It's just that simple.

In my opinion, to be the 'best' of anything concerning fighting, you have to be able to defeat EVERYBODY, no matter what their size, weight, or strength is. Imagine someone walking around on the street saying that they were the greatest fighter in the world or the baddest person in the world. You would naturally interpret them as meaning that they could beat anyone and everyone that they came across. If they were to then say that "No, I mean I'm the greatest fighter or the baddest person in the world when fighting guys that are only my same size and weight", you would . Because that's not truly being the best fighter in the world then, is it?

Johnson was a HEAVYWEIGHT. So we know he can stand toe to toe with smaller boxers as well as the big ones. Can Floyd, at his size, defeat Jack Johnson, whether it be the 1903 Johnson or the 1926 Johnson? If not, then how can be 'better'?

[Scary]

It's still going?! Haha

By your logic, we should just delete all divisions and make one, so we can see who really is the best!

[bojangles1987]

Muhammad Ali is better because he spent 20 years beating better fighters. You don't have to make up threads with this kind of ridiculous logic to make the case.

[Larry the boss]

The Reason George Chuvalo Is Better Than Floyd Mayweather
Because he couldn't beat George Chuvalo in a boxing match, especially a prime Chuvalo. It's just that simple.

In my opinion, to be the 'best' of anything concerning fighting, you have to be able to defeat EVERYBODY, no matter what their size, weight, or strength is. Imagine someone walking around on the street saying that they were the greatest fighter in the world or the baddest person in the world. You would naturally interpret them as meaning that they could beat anyone and everyone that they came across. If they were to then say that "No, I mean I'm the greatest fighter or the baddest person in the world when fighting guys that are only my same size and weight", you would . Because that's not truly being the best fighter in the world then, is it?

Chuvalo was a HEAVYWEIGHT. So we know he can stand toe to toe with smaller boxers as well as the big ones. Can Floyd, at his size, defeat George Chuvalo, whether it be the 60's Chuvalo or the 70's Chuvalo? If not, then how can be 'better'?

[Szef]

Since this is a pretty ****ty thread I might as well hijack it:

If they were the same size, who do you think would win, Floyd or Ali?

[Slip Stream]

The Reason Eric "Butterbean" Esch Is Better Than Floyd Mayweather

Because he couldn't beat Eric "Butterbean" Esch in a boxing match, especially a prime Butterbean. It's just that simple.

In my opinion, to be the 'best' of anything concerning fighting, you have to be able to defeat EVERYBODY, no matter what their size, weight, or strength is. Imagine someone walking around on the street saying that they were the greatest fighter in the world or the baddest person in the world. You would naturally interpret them as meaning that they could beat anyone and everyone that they came across. If they were to then say that "No, I mean I'm the greatest fighter or the baddest person in the world when fighting guys that are only my same size and weight", you would . Because that's not truly being the best fighter in the world then, is it?

Butterbean was a HEAVYWEIGHT. So we know he can stand toe to toe with smaller boxers as well as the big ones. Can Floyd, at his size, defeat Butterbean, whether it be the 1995 Butterbean or the 2005 Butterbean? If not, then how can be 'better'?

[VG_Addict]

Since this is a pretty ****ty thread I might as well hijack it:

If they were the same size, who do you think would win, Floyd or Ali?

I'd give Floyd a chance. He was better technically than Ali.

[BigAlexSand]

The Reason Kimbo Slice is a better boxer than Floyd Mayeather is Because he couldn't beat Kimbo Slice in a boxing match, especially a prime Kimbo. It's just that simple.

In my opinion, to be the 'best' of anything concerning fighting, you have to be able to defeat EVERYBODY, no matter what their size, weight, or strength is. Imagine someone walking around on the street saying that they were the greatest fighter in the world or the baddest person in the world. You would naturally interpret them as meaning that they could beat anyone and everyone that they came across. If they were to then say that "No, I mean I'm the greatest fighter or the baddest person in the world when fighting guys that are only my same size and weight", you would . Because that's not truly being the best fighter in the world then, is it?

Kimbo was a HEAVYWEIGHT. So we know he can stand toe to toe with smaller boxers as well as the big ones. Can Floyd, at his size, defeat Kimbo Slice , whether it be the 2011's Kimbo or the 2013's Kimbo? If not, then how can be 'better'?

[MASTER OF you]

ali is better because he fought and won in the greatest era in heavyweight history without ducking anyone one or waiting until they where past their best.unlike mayflower jr who fake retired when things where starting to heat up in the welterweight division.ali isn't called the greatest for nothing.