Should Same Day Weigh-Ins Return?

[Trinidad_Fan]

JCC Jr. alone brings your argument crashing down in flames. How many people did Junior beat up solely because he was twice as big as them in the ring? What happened when Junior finally fought in the weight division HE BELONGS IN against someone his own size? He got the crap beat out of him (an alltime fav fight for me).

This is boxing, not who can put on the most weight so they can outweigh the other guy by 30 pounds.

Please look at the quality of opponents he was beating, then get back to me.

Oki-doki.

Rubio: better than Junior but ridiculously outweighed the day of the fight.
Lee: better than Junior but ridiculously outweighed the day of the fight.

If you're honestly going to defend Junior just to make a point about weight gain, well........ what can I say.

Like I said, the first time Junior steps into the ring with someone he doesn't outweigh by 30 pounds, he gets his a$$ handed to him. And we're not talking surefire HOF'er in Fonfara either.

The shining example of my point was precisely Martinez. Rarely had such a shutout been pitched in boxing. Scratch that. Shutout isn't good enough. Perfect game is more like it. Boxing lesson. Kid totally out of his league. But Martinez was fighting someone 1 or 2 weight divisions heavier than him in there. Sort of like a matador with a ****** bull in front of him. Only a Hail Mary in the last round made the fight exciting at the end.

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Oki-doki.

Rubio: better than Junior but ridiculously outweighed the day of the fight.
Lee: better than Junior but ridiculously outweighed the day of the fight.

If you're honestly going to defend Junior just to make a point about weight gain, well........ what can I say.

Like I said, the first time Junior steps into the ring with someone he doesn't outweigh by 30 pounds, he gets his a$$ handed to him. And we're not talking surefire HOF'er in Fonfara either.

The shining example of my point was precisely Martinez. Rarely had such a shutout been pitched in boxing. Scratch that. Shutout isn't good enough. Perfect game is more like it. Boxing lesson. Kid totally out of his league. But Martinez was fighting someone 1 or 2 weight divisions heavier than him in there. Sort of like a matador with a ****** bull in front of him. Only a Hail Mary in the last round made the fight exciting at the end.

It looked like a middleweight fighting a heavyweight. Was ridiculous.

The biggest question is

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Is it a fair fight when one guy outweighs the other by a significant amount?

The answer is NO.

[Chuckguy]

Yes they should. Canelo will have to move up to at least 160 as will rios. No more draining picking on smaler guys