What Fighters Would Have Never Been Champions?

[Tony Trick-Pony]

Four division champ doe.

At one time, being a four division champion meant a lot more. There were very few but now there are several. The only reason is more divisions and titles. Three divisions was damn near impossible when there were eight. But two and three division champion was much more respected.

[-PBP-]

Okay so we need to get working on a huge list then to do this lol

Carlos Cuenca
Pauli Malinaggi
Kell Brook
Jamie McDonnell
James Toney (say what you want but when he faced the best of his division he ALWAYS lost)

This list as you said it really could go on and on but those were just a random spurt of guys that came to mind.

James Toney beat Michael Nunn for the lineal Middleweight championship.

Come on NSB. We have to do better this is embarrassing.

[M Bison]

James Toney beat Michael Nunn for the lineal Middleweight championship.

Come on NSB. We have to do better this is embarrassing.

Doesn't excuse the fact he got took to school by someone like Dave Tiberi who wasn't anything special.
James Toney when he stepped up against the BEST of his division ALWAYS lost, that fact remains.

[-PBP-]

Doesn't excuse the fact he got took to school by someone like Dave Tiberi who wasn't anything special.
James Toney when he stepped up against the BEST of his division ALWAYS lost, that fact remains.

Stop deflecting in an attempt to escape your error. OP asked who would have never been a champion. Toney was the real, legitimate Middleweight champion. Dude, you eat fail for breakfast, lunch and dinner and it stems from your hatred for American fighters.

[M Bison]

Stop deflecting in an attempt to escape your error. OP asked who would have never been a champion. Toney was the real, legitimate Middleweight champion. Dude, you eat fail for breakfast, lunch and dinner and it stems from your hatred for American fighters.

James Toney never fought Bernard Hopkins and as soon as he fought a real champion in Roy Jones Jr he got toyed with, he doesn't belong in the same breath as guys who would have been the main champion the guy blatantly ducked many big fights such as Eubank Sr, Nigel Benn and so on all because he wanted to hide away in America fighting guys like Dave Tiberi
Then he goes on to losing in a Prize Fighter tournament to a former sparring partner hahahahahahahaha!!

[-PBP-]

James Toney never fought Bernard Hopkins and as soon as he fought a real champion in Roy Jones Jr he got toyed with, he doesn't belong in the same breath as guys who would have been the main champion the guy blatantly ducked many big fights such as Eubank Sr, Nigel Benn and so on all because he wanted to hide away in America fighting guys like Dave Tiberi
Then he goes on to losing in a Prize Fighter tournament to a former sparring partner hahahahah anahahaha!!

Woooowww. This post reaks of failure mixed with DKSAB. He fought Roy Jones at 168 and Hopkins wasn't even in the picture when Toney was Middleweight champion.

[M Bison]

Woooowww. This post reaks of failure mixed with DKSAB. He fought Roy Jones at 168 and Hopkins wasn't even in the picture when Toney was Middleweight champion.

Hid in USA fighting guys like Dave Tiberi, oh I can't come to Britain
"huurmmm uurmmm gaargh guuh dey fite me"
Dude was made punch drunk by non-hitters like Tiberi and other pillow punchers imagine how badly he'd be beat up in this current era, doesn't even seem fair what an overrated hype-job he is but he American doe but he black n doe de shoulder roll I gotta stick with him because Floyd doe.

Topic clearly says who'd be the main champion regardless and Toney got constant gifts throughout his hyped up MW career

Now look at him, punch drunk even worse than before and losing to guys like Gavern and god knows who else but
"he be champion in era of just one main guy"


Hilarious!

[Luilun]

Baldomir actually beat the man at 147. Nice try.

You need to read the article again Baldimor would have never won a title with one champ neither would have Judah

[gauze]

James Toney never fought Bernard Hopkins and as soon as he fought a real champion in Roy Jones Jr he got toyed with, he doesn't belong in the same breath as guys who would have been the main champion the guy blatantly ducked many big fights such as Eubank Sr, Nigel Benn and so on all because he wanted to hide away in America fighting guys like Dave Tiberi
Then he goes on to losing in a Prize Fighter tournament to a former sparring partner hahahahahahahaha!!

OHHH....you mean them WBO "champions"?

[gauze]

You need to read the article again Baldimor would have never won a title with one champ neither would have Judah

so you're saying that if mosley and de la hoya didnt fight for the number 1 spot at 147, and if vernon forrest didn't beat mosley, and mayorga didn't knock out forrest, and spinks didn't decision mayorga...who got knocked out by judah....there's some other champion who didn't exist that would have been the champion instead of those guys? who would have been the champion then?

i wanna slap so many people in this thread.