This is a down right amazing breakdown

[Reloaded]

Nah its like this: Marciano and his opponents operated under different conditions. To compare eras, you have to apply those same conditions to Floyd. Basic logic.



I merely pointed out how statistics can be skewed when gathered and compared from different eras. It's not as simple as all that, as I have clearly demonstrated. And it's amusing you talk down to me; I'm a grown ass man in my prime that done forgot more than you ever learned. But the net allows for all sorts of things I suppose.

Floyd is well conditioned.. but ref protected. In another era he would not have been. Interested to know how Maidana 1 would have gone without fast breaks in the last half. Also I'd be interested to know how the first Castillo fight would have gone for 3 more rounds, since Floyd was struggling with an injury.

Always ends up the same woulda coulda shoulda , as a grown ass man you should know better .

[Syf]

Always ends up the same woulda coulda shoulda , as a grown ass man you should know better .

Then don't compare two different eras.

[b00g13man]

Nah its like this: Marciano and his opponents operated under different conditions. To compare eras, you have to apply those same conditions to Floyd. Basic logic.

Same conditions like competing in 5 different weight classes right?

[b d w]

Did they KO all their opponents , I dont think they did and many were not near the class of Floyds resume , you guys just blurt out crap that has no weight and you think sounds good , its all about trying to lower Floyd at any cost its just so pathetic .

I think Floyd is a fine fighter, top 30 of all time which is a helluva achievement, but he should go down on his knees everyday and thank the Lord that he didn't exist in the era of Duran, Leonard and Hearns.

[Reloaded]

I think Floyd is a fine fighter, top 30 of all time which is a helluva achievement, but he should go down on his knees everyday and thank the Lord that he didn't exist in the era of Duran, Leonard and Hearns.

Would be interesting , Floyd would beat the like of Esteban DeJesus and 99% of anyone on there resumes , so he would be highly competitive especially at 135-140 , could he be undefeated probably not .

I dont believe anybody his size will just wipe him out his defense is that good , I believe he could compete in any era in the history of boxing .

I dont go for the best in history for any guy you will never hear me talk that stuff , I think that stuff is fan BS , I believe the top guys if they were in a horse race and as they crossed the finished line you could throw a blanket over the whole field with very little between them , run the same race next week and you have a different result .

[baya]

Is this your way of saying you don't actually have the answer to both questions?

just laughing at the laziness you displayed in your post; boxrec?

[b00g13man]

just laughing at the laziness you displayed in your post; boxrec?

Laziness? Mentioning someone fighting in the 15 round era when said fighter didn't have many 15 round fights isn't valid?

[baya]

Laziness? Mentioning someone fighting in the 15 round era when said fighter didn't have many 15 round fights isn't valid?

oh - i literally thought you didn't know the answer to the question you posed.

anyway, yeah, he only fought like 5 of those 15 rounders, only going the distance juance.

[b00g13man]

oh - i literally thought you didn't know the answer to the question you posed.

anyway, yeah, he only fought like 5 of those 15 rounders, only going the distance juance.

Aaaaaah. My bad also. We both got our wires crossed.

[Reloaded]

Then don't compare two different eras.

I didnt , Im looking at 2 different fighters on face value after watching them fight and Floyd is waaaaaaaaay better than Marciano as a professional boxer , its nots close at all , to go down your imaginary route if Floyd was a HW he box circles around Rocky and win every round in a total shut out .