True or False: James Toney's win over Michael Nunn is better than any win of Floyd's?

[Ahmed_Ismail]

Pacquiao was a monster in 2009! That was 6 years ago he KO'd Cotto you fool.

u can't be this dumb, read the comment again, he was declared a monster in 2009, Cotto got KTFO in 2008, does that mean Pacquiao waited for Cotto to get KOed? Floyd fought Cotto in 2012, 2012-2008=4

[Pac=Duran]

I've seen all these fights, and I don't have to see a fight to know that these people were moving up in weight to fight Nunn, they were unranked at middleweight, which doesn't prove much at middleweight.

You just admitted to being a boxrec warrior! I can obviously tell from the way you've been posting that you have seen very little, if any footage of Nunn outside of the Toney KO round.

[LacedUp]

Starling was jumping up 2 weight classes to fight Nunn and he still got a MD, and Curry never fought at 160 before this fight either and he had some losses to D level fighters, if u call these "impressive wins" I don't know what to tell u.

Dude stop it. You're out of your depth.

[Pac=Duran]

u can't be this dumb, read the comment again, he was declared a monster in 2009, Cotto got KTFO in 2008, does that mean Pacquiao waited for Cotto to get KOed? Floyd fought Cotto in 2012, 2012-2008=4

Talking about guys jumping up weight classes and saying that it means a win is lessened> B-Hops best win was a career welterweight coming up weight classes. Floyd's best win is a diminished version of a career junior bantamweight who started at 108 pounds. Nunn's resume is legit as ****, and Toney's win over him is far better than any individual win Floyd has.

The people have spoken anyway look at the poll/.

[Ahmed_Ismail]

Talking about guys jumping up weight classes and saying that it means a win is lessened> B-Hops best win was a career welterweight coming up weight classes. Floyd's best win is a diminished version of a career junior bantamweight who started at 108 pounds. Nunn's resume is legit as ****, and Toney's win over him is far better than any individual win Floyd has.

The people have spoken anyway look at the poll/.

What about growing into the weight, Manny has been fighting at 147 for 6 years, Curry and Starling where having their first fights at 160, a huge difference!

[Pac=Duran]

What about growing into the weight, Manny has been fighting at 147 for 6 years, Curry and Starling where having their first fights at 160, a huge difference!

Enough bullshlt, the people have spoken as the the answer of the original question. Toney over Nunn> Any of Floyd's win.

[No Tomorrow]

So u judge fighters by potential? not by actual accomplishments? and u call me a bum? How is that supposed to make sense, u r giving Nunn credit for things he never did, he displayed his skills against subpar competition but when he faced other ATG fighters he lost, all the would'ves should've and could'ves don't matter, what he accomplished in the ring is what matters, Joan Guzman was a very skillful fighter with a lot of potential, did he have ATG accomplishments? NO, which doesn't make him an ATG. Nunn had a better career than Guzman, but also him didn't reach that ATG level, when he stepped to the big time he lost, live with it.

KO1 over Sumbu Kalambay is an incredible win. Please know what you're talking about. It's embarrassing

[Pac=Duran]

KO1 over Sumbu Kalambay is an incredible win. Please know what you're talking about. It's embarrassing

He's nothing more than a Floyd defender that fails to recognise the greater degree of difficulty in building a career in times gone by, and the all-around greater era that the early and mid 90s was.

[Johnwoo8686]

Even at his best, Pacquaio never approached Nunn Skill wise. I love Manny as a fighter, becuase he consistently won fights he shouldn't have been able to win.

He was not special for his skill, he was special for his ability to win the big fights he wasnt suppose to win.

What fights were those? He was the favorite against Morales in the first and second fight. He was the favorite against Hatton and Cotto, He was the favorite against Marquez in all four fights. The only fight where he was the underdog and still came out on top was against De La Hoya. And De La Hoya was a shell of himself.

With that said, Pacquiao is far more accomplished than Nunn. Freddie Roach has said James Toney was more talented than Manny. But Toney is nowhere near as accomplished as Manny. That's why I say Manny is a bigger win than Nunn.

[Pac=Duran]

What fights were those? He was the favorite against Morales in the first and second fight. He was the favorite against Hatton and Cotto, He was the favorite against Marquez in all four fights. The only fight where he was the underdog and still came out on top was against De La Hoya. And De La Hoya was a shell of himself.

With that said, Pacquiao is far more accomplished than Nunn. Freddie Roach has said James Toney was more talented than Manny. But Toney is nowhere near as accomplished as Manny. That's why I say Manny is a bigger win than Nunn.

Ledwaba, Sasakul, Barrera and Oscar. Huge underdog in everyone.