Would Floyd be the GOAT?

[Xi_]

Floyd sucks.

if floyd sucks then what does that say about GGG?

[Boxing Goat]

He was the WBA regular champion and then they elevated him to full champion when he didn't fight Felix Sturm


He didn't even beat a champion or titlist for the belt


Mayweather has never won a vacant title his entire career

Excuse me, where did I compare their resume's in this thread?

I said GGG has a good resume and has beaten some tough fighters, some who were undefeated and some who were world champions/challengers.

[Boxing Goat]

Yes,he is collecting vacant titles,same thing Cotto was getting slammed for at 140 and 147

You can't fight nor beat guys who are scared to fight you

[Mr.Fantastic]

you're an idiot and a racist.....you race bait without even realizing it.

EDIT: Shouldn't have called you an idiot......apology to you. You did race bait though.

I'm probably going to vote for Dr. Ben Carson, a black guy for president. Yup I'm totally racist dawg!

[Boxing Goat]

Smh. Here is yet another Fanboy thread. Stop trying to find all of these different scenarios where Floyd could be GOAT. There isn't one, PERIOD! He has no balls or fighting heart. So, how could any of your scenarios amount to "GOAT"??? On top of all of that, Floyd is fighting in a weaker era and he still won't fight the very best. You cannot give this insecure fighter/man, BALLS! The end! He won't even fight outside of Vegas. All great fighters do that. He waited five years to fight Manny. He ducked Paul Williams. Prime De La Hoya. Cotto. Cheeto. Bradley. Khan. GGG. He drained Canelo. This dude is a con artist and an overrated HOF'mer. He's NOT an ATG. No way. You idiots need to stop overrating him and Roy Jones no chin ass! It's redundant.

Lol @ Fanboy!!!

As I've said earlier in this thread, I'm not even a Floyd fan. At all!

I literally cannot stand the guy.......but.......

I acknowledge his fistic brilliance and respect his game and what he's done in and for boxing.

Say what you want but he's beaten the very best his weight has had to offer at one point or another in his career. In fact, even though I think Pac mostly lost because of his injury, he did lose to Floyd and he was considered the second best of the era. That means Floyd has beaten all comers at 147 and the next best fighter of the era. He's proven to be pretty much unbeatable (aside from Castillo-I) and is going on 39 years of age. That's far better than other ATG's have done at the age. Remember, Ali was already long retired by that age.

[Xi_]

I'm probably going to vote for Dr. Ben Carson, a black guy for president. Yup I'm totally racist dawg!

90% of your post are race driven and bias against black fighters.....there could be a thread about ice cream and you would find some way to bring race into the discussion.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

game over......

[IMDAZED]

Why would beating GGG accomplish that? Who has GGG beaten? He's just another champ.

[b00g13man]

Why would it?

[NEETzsche]

Why would beating GGG accomplish that? Who has GGG beaten? He's just another champ.

well it would certainly top floyd's win over canelo, which is regarded by all as one of his crowning achievements

golovkin is a soon-to-be unified champion and top 10 p4per at the height of his powers, two full divisions above floyd's optimal one. hypothetically, if mayweather were to beat him it would be a huge deal. but he's not going to fight him, and nor should he be expected to, so this is all academic anyway