Would Floyd be the GOAT?

[Larry the boss]

If Floyd beat Golovkin at 154 people would say he was drained.

Floyd couldn't be the GOAT regardless but in the eyes of these fans he beat both Klitschko brothers on the same night and they still wouldn't give him credit.

How many times over the years have fans on here said Floyd is ducking someone then after he beats them discredit it? Numerous times now.

And I'm talking immediately before these fights happen.

^^^^100 percent this...look how quick the Manny fight got torn apart

[Eff Pandas]

He's already in the discussion & probably has been in the discussion since after De La Hoya.

[Larry the boss]

by fight 33 mayweather was already lineal in 2 divisions(11 total defenses) and had his first fight in a 3rd one


Mayeather had a better resume than ggg does now after his 3-5 years in the game



GGG is another overrated puncher who gets hyped but resume is lacking.

Yep^^^all true.

[Boxing Goat]

He has literally been handed title belts man

So when you fight and beat another ranked contender to the belt to earn it when the title holder is not available to beat for it, it's considered being simply 'handed' to you? You should try thinking logically and objectively.

Just go check out the Ring, ESPN and Boxrec P4P rankings if I cannot convince you of his boxing ranking and mastery.

[Larry the boss]

So when you fight and beat another ranked contender to the belt to earn it when the title holder is not available to beat for it, it's considered being simply 'handed' to you? You should try thinking logically and objectively.

Just go check out the Ring, ESPN and Boxrec P4P rankings if I cannot convince you of his boxing ranking and mastery.

Yes,he is collecting vacant titles,same thing Cotto was getting slammed for at 140 and 147

[Johnwoo8686]

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

Are you seriously comparing GGG's resume and Floyd's resume? That is just ignorant. One guy has defeated multiple world champions through five weight classes while the other has yet to face a decent fighter in the one weight class he competes in. These guys are not even comparable.

[GOD-FR33]

Smh again.........

Smh. Here is yet another Fanboy thread. Stop trying to find all of these different scenarios where Floyd could be GOAT. There isn't one, PERIOD! He has no balls or fighting heart. So, how could any of your scenarios amount to "GOAT"??? On top of all of that, Floyd is fighting in a weaker era and he still won't fight the very best. You cannot give this insecure fighter/man, BALLS! The end! He won't even fight outside of Vegas. All great fighters do that. He waited five years to fight Manny. He ducked Paul Williams. Prime De La Hoya. Cotto. Cheeto. Bradley. Khan. GGG. He drained Canelo. This dude is a con artist and an overrated HOF'mer. He's NOT an ATG. No way. You idiots need to stop overrating him and Roy Jones no chin ass! It's redundant.

[Weltschmerz]

Floyd and GGG's resume are not even in the same universe

Floyd sucks.

[Johnwoo8686]

Smh. Here is yet another Fanboy thread. Stop trying to find all of these different scenarios where Floyd could be GOAT. There isn't one, PERIOD! He has no balls or fighting heart. So, how could any of your scenarios amount to "GOAT"??? On top of all of that, Floyd is fighting in a weaker era and he still won't fight the very best. You cannot give this insecure fighter/man, BALLS! The end! He won't even fight outside of Vegas. All great fighters do that. He waited five years to fight Manny. He ducked Paul Williams. Prime De La Hoya. Cotto. Cheeto. Bradley. Khan. GGG. He drained Canelo. This dude is a con artist and an overrated HOF'mer. He's NOT an ATG. No way. You idiots need to stop overrating him and Roy Jones no chin ass! It's redundant.

Half of Floyd's total career fights have been outside of Vegas.. stop saying things that are not true. It was Manny who walked away from fighting Floyd five years ago and his team always had an excuse as to why the fight didn't happen. First it was blood testing, then Manny had a cut that needed extra time to heal, then they needed to build a stadium. All of those excuses magically disappeared when Manny's PPV sales started to sink after the Marquez KO.
You guys consider Manny a great fighter but he didn't fight most of the guys you listed either. De La Hoya was drained and past his prime and Manny considers that his biggest win. GTFOH

[Xi_]

Naw beating Ward under 168 would mean Ward was drained and he would get 0 credit,plus it would just be a circus show

i should have said andre ward type of fighter with an andre ward resume.