Would Floyd be the GOAT?

[Boxing Goat]

Poll Question: If Floyd were to fight and beat GGG at or above 154 lbs., would you consider him in the discussion for the greatest boxer of all time?

[Larry the boss]

Why would beating GGG at 154 make him the Goat?? GGG's best win is Martin ****ing Murray,He has not defeated 1 current champion and is now facing Lemiuex who just won a vacant belt and he himself never beat anyone...GGGis so hyped on here it is crazy...his resume is worse then Maidana's and even Berto's..

[Mr.Fantastic]

Why would beating GGG at 154 make him the Goat?? GGG's best win is Martin ****ing Murray,He has not defeated 1 current champion and is now facing Lemiuex who just won a vacant belt and he himself never beat anyone...GGGis so hyped on here it is crazy...his resume is worse then Maidana's and even Berto's..

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

[Szef]

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

Touche.

[Larry the boss]

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

Floyd and GGG's resume are not even in the same universe

[BrometheusBob.]

Poll Question: If Floyd were to fight and beat GGG at or above 154 lbs., would you consider him in the discussion for the greatest boxer of all time?

It could only help his case to take a risk of that magnitude, but I would think it's reasonable if he does not.

[Boxing Goat]

Why would beating GGG at 154 make him the Goat?? GGG's best win is Martin ****ing Murray,He has not defeated 1 current champion and is now facing Lemiuex who just won a vacant belt and he himself never beat anyone...GGGis so hyped on here it is crazy...his resume is worse then Maidana's and even Berto's..

Because he started fighting at 130 lbs. maybe?

I'm not a Floyd fan, but that would make a great step in the direction of him being one of, if not the best to lace them up.

That would be simply amazing. GGG is a beast no matter how weak you think his comp has been, (16 title defenses don't lie bud).

[Xi_]

Now you know how we feel when Floyd fans make Floyd's resume look like the best thing ever when in reality, it isn't.

it's still a top 20-25 resume which is nothing to laugh about......if you're top 20 you have every right to "think" you're the best.

[FrankieClutch]

I've said it in the past and I'll say it again, Floyd's "GOAT" ship has sailed. He's a great fighter and has a good resume, but he isn't #1. Top 10, maybe. Top 15 for sure

[Mr.Fantastic]

Floyd and GGG's resume are not even in the same universe

Really? Didn't know that.

it's still a top 20-25 resume which is nothing to laugh about......if you're top 20 you have every right to "think" you're the best.

What are Floyd's top 10 wins? If you don't mind me asking.