Rank your Wleterweights

[WarMaidana]

Chaves + Guerrero > Porter.

agreed. But Porter is a good win, but thats really the only impressive win

[hhs661]

Mayweather
Brook
Bradley
Manny
Porter
Khan
Thurman
Maidana
Alexander
Chaves

[torosboxing75]

Nobody's going to agree with my list but I'm going by the skill and potential I see in each fighter.

1 Floyd
2 Spence Jr
3 Pacquiao
4 Brook/Thurman
5 Brook/Thurman
6 Bradley
7 khan
8 Maidana
9 Porter
10 Ali

Spence is sooo talented IDC if he hasn't fought any top guys yet. I know enough about boxing that I can say with confidence Spence is the future p4p king when Floyd retires IMO. You can take that to the bank.

[Showtime..]

Champion: Mayweather
#1 Manny Pacquiao
#2 Kell Brook
#3 Bradley
#4 Porter
#5 Thurman
#6 Maidana
#7 Amir Khan
#8 Devon Alexander
#9 Guerrero
#10 Rios/Chaves or someone like that-

Left Marquez out because he's been inactive for more than a year.

Guerrero Top Ten? Are you buzzed? The dude went life and death with a pseudo Alex Leapei..

Don't hype Thurman's best win. It's garbage. He couldn't even 12-0 him like Floyd. I would say the Chaves KO is his best.

[soul_survivor]

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. Bradley
4. Maidana
5. Thurman
6. Brook
7. Porter
8. Khan
9. Alexander
10. Spence/Rios/Chaves (pick em at 10)

You know things have gone wrong when Thurman is ranked above a current title holder and two guys a fight removed from losing their title.

[soul_survivor]

Nobody's going to agree with my list but I'm going by the skill and potential I see in each fighter.

1 Floyd
2 Spence Jr
3 Pacquiao
4 Brook/Thurman
5 Brook/Thurman
6 Bradley
7 khan
8 Maidana
9 Porter
10 Ali

Spence is sooo talented IDC if he hasn't fought any top guys yet. I know enough about boxing that I can say with confidence Spence is the future p4p king when Floyd retires IMO. You can take that to the bank.

I'm willing to give Spence a chance and I see what you're trying with your list, going off of skills and potential but I don't see it in Spence, I really don't. His feet are flat, he throws looping, wide shots and his power looks good against d level opponents so I'm not even sure about that.

[thiefery]

I'm willing to give Spence a chance and I see what you're trying with your list, going off of skills and potential but I don't see it in Spence, I really don't. His feet are flat, he throws looping, wide shots and his power looks good against d level opponents so I'm not even sure about that.

I agree,not saying Errol won't be nice,but the jury is still out on him. But since Floyd has hand chosen him to be his successor, for now, see a lot of people jumping on his bandwagon.

These lists don't really matter much right now when the gap between #2 Pac & the rest of the division is huge.

This division has been carried by Floyd & Manny for the past 5 years. This isn't the killer division that was 2005

[LacedUp]

Guerrero Top Ten? Are you buzzed? The dude went life and death with a pseudo Alex Leapei..

Don't hype Thurman's best win. It's garbage. He couldn't even 12-0 him like Floyd. I would say the Chaves KO is his best.

I have no problems ranking him outside the top 10. But it didn't feel right with me putting someone like sadam ali in there.

Well, Thurman is not Mayweather? It's hardly anything saying "he couldn't even.. like mayweather" - Mayweather is the best ***ing fighter on the planet and I'd say Thurman handled him pretty well and dropped him hard.

[LacedUp]

By beating Chaves, Guerrero, Bundu, Zaveck. All good fighters. Aexander's got a good win over Chino, but he's lost to Porter, Kotelnik, Amir. Thurman beats those guys.

I am a fight fan, it's just ******ed to think Alexander is a better welterweight than Thurman.

I agree. Alexander would get hammered pretty badly by Thurman.

[soul_survivor]

I agree,not saying Errol won't be nice,but the jury is still out on him. But since Floyd has hand chosen him to be his successor, for now, see a lot of people jumping on his bandwagon.

These lists don't really matter much right now when the gap between #2 Pac & the rest of the division is huge.

This division has been carried by Floyd & Manny for the past 5 years. This isn't the killer division that was 2005

Pretty much this, it's a mediocre division at best and the gap between the best and the rest is far too much.

I agree. Alexander would get hammered pretty badly by Thurman.

Well then, maybe Thurman should try and prove that then.