Rank your Wleterweights

[W1LL]

Just browsing Boxrec, I have no recollection of Alexander's win over Maidana.

[kiaba360]

Just browsing Boxrec, I have no recollection of Alexander's win over Maidana.

It was one of the ugliest fights in recent memory. Alexander and Maidana made their debuts @WW against one another, and it's clear that Devon was in better shape at the new weight. I think Devon gets more credit for that win than he should.

Alexander: Khan, Soto-Karass, Porter, Purdy, Bailey, Maidana.

[FrankieClutch]

1. Floyd
2. Manny
3. Bradley
4. Maidana
5. Thurman
6. Brook
7. Porter
8. Khan
9. Alexander
10. Spence/Rios/Chaves (pick em at 10)

[b00g13man]

-Thurman: Collazo, Ghost, Bundu, Diaz, Soto-Karass, Chaves, Zaveck, Quintana
-Maidana: Mayweather x2, Broner, Alexander, Lopez, Soto-Karass, Martinez

Chino has the better names, while Thurman has campaigned longer at WW. Maidana is 4-3 while Thurman is undefeated. Thurman has also had fewer shaky moments at WW. The only person that Thurman would lose to on Chino's WW resume is Floyd. I'm itching for Thurman to get a notable opponent, and if Chino can get back into fighting shape, maybe we'll get this bout early next year.

Broner (I don't think much of him at all btw) and an 8-4 type loss to Floyd > anything on Thurman's resume to me. I find it hard to rate him higher when his best win is Guerrero.

[HEND]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Timothy Bradley
4. Kell Brook
5. Keith Thurman
6. Marcos Maidana
7. Shawn Porter
8. Amir Khan
9. Robert Guerrero
10. Diego Chaves


HM (10-15): Sadam Ali, Errol Spence, Devon Alexander, Brandon Rios, Leonard Bundu

Probably Chaves or Guerrero will be out soon and Danny Garcia will enter.

[jas]

Robert Guerrero is past it

There's no way he's top ten

[kiaba360]

Broner (I don't think much of him at all btw) and an 8-4 type loss to Floyd > anything on Thurman's resume to me. I find it hard to rate him higher when his best win is Guerrero.

Broner is 1-2 at WW, and one of them was at a CW and his only win was against the weakest WW in a competitive fight. Maidana beat the hype off of Broner, but that win probably won't age all that well. Can Maidana beat the hype off of Thurman? Hopefully that match-up happens.

[jas]

A ranking list should be based on who you think wins the most fights vs the rest of the top 10

It's not made based solely on resume

A resume can be used as an indicator as to the fighters ability however

I'm glad to have cleared things up

[alexguiness]

1. mayweather
2. pacquiao
3. brook
4. bradley
5. thurman
6. maidana
7. porter
8. khan
9. ali
10. spence jr

I see it something like this as well.

[WarMaidana]

1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Bradley
4. Maidana
5. Thurman
6. Brook
7. Porter
8. Khan
9. Rios
10. Chaves