How would Ali fare in todays HW division?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • low blows
    Undisputed Champion
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2005
    • 1258
    • 195
    • 2
    • 10,313

    #111
    Originally posted by nerd slapper
    Jennings has a better physique than Ali did as a true heavyweight (190 lbs doesn't count.. By 230 Ali was getting fat) much less ali's disgusting exercise allergic opponents like buster mathis and joe frazier.

    Better focus on the alleged "skill gap". The every modern hw is Chris Arreola angle is spent. Historical heavies had one thing going for them... They were American.

    Even low quality barroom/caveman-style fighters like Frazier who lost athletics tournaments to a race car driver and couldn't run 100 yards without having an asthma attack despite being an average sized guy got enough media exposure to seem like epic wins in that claustrophobic era.

    That pathetic low garbage standard was a "clash of the titans" when network TV and the mob were on the same page and the world outside of the US/UK was just starting to take interest.
    Joe Frazier was never fat in his prime. He was a short smallish heavyweight for his era. In his prime at 195 he was quite low body fat. After he beat Ali he ballooned up when he fought local heroes like Daniels and Stander but those were tune up fights. Diet and nutritional knowledge were basic compared to today. So were training methods. Frazier only did a morning run, then ate breakfast took a short nap then did warm up exercises, then worked on his skills and sparred for a few hours and after that took the day off and ate on schedule.

    These days Wlad does that in the morning/early afternoon and in the evening he would do more exercises.
    Last edited by low blows; 04-27-2015, 09:26 PM.

    Comment

    • Elroy1
      Undisputed Champion
      Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
      • Jun 2014
      • 6561
      • 237
      • 61
      • 14,370

      #112
      With modern day training meaning for pure athleticism and strength and nutrition for size, it would make him more competitive but the fact remains he was a bummy boxer!

      The guy just didn't have enough skills to compete today! Plain and simple! That rubbish was fine back in the day but who is it gonna threaten today?

      Tyson Fury is a modern day Ali. It takes a guy the size of Fury who has similar skillset to make that work.

      No matter how much training or food you pumped into Ali, he would never have been as formidable as Fury.

      That is just a fact, get over it!

      As for if he was trained in modern skills, well then OBVIOUSLY he would no longer even BE Muhammad Ali!

      If you taught him to dodge punches, to hit properly and all that stuff, he would no longer be the punch bag weakling you all love anyway!

      Comment

      • Elroy1
        Undisputed Champion
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Jun 2014
        • 6561
        • 237
        • 61
        • 14,370

        #113
        Originally posted by low blows
        Joe Frazier was never fat in his prime. He was a short smallish heavyweight for his era. In his prime at 195 he was quite low body fat. After he beat Ali he ballooned up when he fought local heroes like Daniels and Stander but those were tune up fights. Diet and nutritional knowledge were basic compared to today. So were training methods. Frazier only did a morning run, then ate breakfast took a short nap then did warm up exercises, then worked on his skills and sparred for a few hours and after that took the day off and ate on schedule.

        These days Wlad does that in the morning/early afternoon and in the evening he would do more exercises.
        Joe Frazier prime 195lbs?

        His best win was Ali when he weighed 210+lbs.

        195lbs is not even a real HW. In fact you'll struggle to find any Cruiser coming in as that even on weigh in!

        And how experienced was Joe at that weight too?

        This myth is busted and this poster should be boycotted for such baseless trash talk.

        He was a fat little bum mate. Deal with it!

        Comment

        • Elroy1
          Undisputed Champion
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Jun 2014
          • 6561
          • 237
          • 61
          • 14,370

          #114
          Originally posted by -Weltschmerz-
          He beat Haye and Jennings convincingly.
          More the point as if Haye and Jennings wouldn't have simply destroyed Ali themselves anyway.

          Look at Ali, look at them!

          Comment

          • Elroy1
            Undisputed Champion
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Jun 2014
            • 6561
            • 237
            • 61
            • 14,370

            #115
            Originally posted by New England
            joe frazier had bad stamina?

            is that what you're trying to tell me?
            It's not hard to go 15 ****ing rounds when you weigh as much as a modern HW's leg, barely ****ing move your body and hit with all the power of an electric shaver you ****in idiot!

            Ali lost to about 11 bums and cruisers!

            Norton, x3
            Frazier x2
            Shavers
            Lyle
            Young
            Jones
            Holmes
            Berbick

            These fights which were given to Ali were blatant gifts and can't possibly viewed otherwise. He lost them!

            Was extremely lucky, cheated and had strange circumstances in Foreman.

            Some would say lost to Cooper also or atleast cheated to survive.

            Then there was farcial scoring and other circumstances in many other fights also, we all know them.

            None of these guys could box today man, Lyle and Foreman might have been able to have some success at low level but come on, a 220lb plodder puncher?

            Unless you can move like Haye or something you ain't plodding at that weight OR hitting like Foreman did either.

            Comment

            • Weltschmerz
              Sehnsucht
              Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
              • Mar 2010
              • 16546
              • 698
              • 1,622
              • 27,699

              #116
              Originally posted by nerd slapper
              Jennings has a better physique than Ali did as a true heavyweight (190 lbs doesn't count.. By 230 Ali was getting fat) much less ali's disgusting exercise allergic opponents like buster mathis and joe frazier.

              Better focus on the alleged "skill gap". The every modern hw is Chris Arreola angle is spent. Historical heavies had one thing going for them... They were American.

              Even low quality barroom/caveman-style fighters like Frazier who lost athletics tournaments to a race car driver and couldn't run 100 yards without having an asthma attack despite being an average sized guy got enough media exposure to seem like epic wins in that claustrophobic era.

              That pathetic low garbage standard was a "clash of the titans" when network TV and the mob were on the same page and the world outside of the US/UK was just starting to take interest.
              Excellent points made.

              Comment

              • Mick6
                Contender
                Silver Champion - 100-500 posts
                • Aug 2013
                • 182
                • 7
                • 6
                • 6,706

                #117
                Please tell me you are just trolling.

                Comment

                Working...
                TOP