Is Cotto Overrated?

[icha]

Cotto hasn't signed to fight anyone yet, it's Canelo who's already busy. How is that keeping the Cotto/Canelo fight from happening lmao.

of course the entire boxing world is blaming canelo for that...
oh wait, never mind...

[shade darkar]

depends where you rate him. iv just seen some guy call cotto a top 5 fighter of his generation!! how can that be when you have lost your biggest fights, collected a few vacant trinkets and dethroned a faded Sergio Martinez?!!

but anyway, id imagine most sane boxing fans would rate cotto somewhere in the bottom half of the top 10 p4p list at the moment. I think that's about right.

[ramses07]

Cotto belongs a lot more than JMM, who did he beat please tell me. Let Cotto roid up and give him 40+ rounds to beat Manny, I think he can do it too. JMM is nobody when you remove Manny's name.

ok man, aside from the jmm, i still wouldn't put him with the pacquiaos or mayweathers

[bigjavi973]

they cant beat him if they cant get him into the ring...

so cotto ducks mexican fighters now? oh wow

[bigjavi973]

of course the entire boxing world is blaming canelo for that...
oh wait, never mind...

only the canelo fans are the ones complaining. "the entire boxing world" is actually calling for GGG-Cotto instead, I am one of those people.

[icha]

so cotto ducks mexican fighters now? oh wow

rubio, canelo and the mexican style(GGG), thats 3 in less than a year...ok 2...

[Beater_of_ass]

depends where you rate him. iv just seen some guy call cotto a top 5 fighter of his generation!! how can that be when you have lost your biggest fights, collected a few vacant trinkets and dethroned a faded Sergio Martinez?!!

but anyway, id imagine most sane boxing fans would rate cotto somewhere in the bottom half of the top 10 p4p list at the moment. I think that's about right.

His biggest fights are Floyd/Manny/Martinez/Shane in that exact order... he's 50/50. So please tell me how he loses his biggest fights again. He is number 3 of the era behind Manny and Floyd, easily. Who's done better, I'll be waiting.

[Beater_of_ass]

of course the entire boxing world is blaming canelo for that...
oh wait, never mind...

Didn't the entire boxing world say Cotto was going to get killed by Martinez? Didn't the boxing world say Mike Tyson was going to kill Douglas? The boxing world doesn't know **** lmao, that's your defense. All my other Mexican fans think it's Cotto's fault too, this guy lol.

[Beater_of_ass]

ok man, aside from the jmm, i still wouldn't put him with the pacquiaos or mayweathers

In ATG status, no. But of his era... yes, he really is.

[shade darkar]

His biggest fights are Floyd/Manny/Martinez/Shane in that exact order... he's 50/50. So please tell me how he loses his biggest fights again. He is number 3 of the era behind Manny and Floyd, easily. Who's done better, I'll be waiting.

course he is!!!! you may be delusional, but I aint, so feel free to reply to other posters thanks!