The Greatest Fighter of Our Era?

[Ryannn]

You see, Mayweather fans are real boxing fans, They appreciate the art of great defensive boxing.

So called Pacquiao fans (aka Mayweather haters) are not real boxing fans. They are just haters, They pray on the downfall of the Great Floyd Mayweather. They just want too see him lose, And it doesn't really matter to them who beats him.

They don't care that Pacquiao was beaten by Bradly, Knocked out by Marquez. They just want the man they hate to fail because they can't stand his success

[kurt0411]

Tbh I don't think there's a lot in it between those four but it just has to be manny at the end of the day. We've never seen anything like him and we never will see

[pasawayako]

Pac and no one comes close to his achievements.

[lefthook2daliva]

1 asian against 3 blacks

Immediately divides the group by racial demographic and declares them adversaries.

Must be a ********.

On topic:

By belts and accomplishments in general, I gotta go with Pac despite that he was KTFO in his prime, but with the caveat that we're not gonna include any alleged ped bull****.

By who would most likely beat up the others were they all magically resized in perfect proportion to a common weight class, I go with Roy.

To me the latter is the more interesting discussion because it seems to me that it's more about eyeball , peak performances and styles vs triangle theories and less about belts, reigns and longevity and their perceived value respectively.

[brown_knight06]

Best boxer is Sweet Pea. Manny has achieved so much.

[pasawayako]

Numbers don't lie. - flom0s

[The Big Dunn]

Numbers don't lie. - flom0s

True, that's why I think the numbers in the rankings of my sig are important.

[FerFAL]

What kind of question is that? Manny Pacquiao of course and there's not even a serious runner up.

[-PBP-]

True, that's why I think the numbers in the rankings of my sig are important.

That Ring Magazine panel is biased and uninformed. I bet most of them weren't even watching boxing until 2008. NSB is way more neutral in determining fighters legacy.

[Pac=Duran]

What kind of question is that? Manny Pacquiao of course and there's not even a serious runner up.

That's how I feel. Marquez is probably above Mayweather in terms of greatness due to his performance in the Pacquiao fights.