Who is the greatest fighter since Muhammed Ali?

[Left Hook Tua]

Hopkins, Morales, Chavez are greater than wlad and Lewis...

the dumb indian is not given enough due for being past prime and beating prime pac.

especially after surviving the 3 beatings the great marco antonio barrera gave him.

[The Big Dunn]

Jose Luis Castillo is not a southpaw

Dunn going all out to slurp Floyd's man milk again

My mistake then. He is still generally considered one of the best LW's ever and Floyd did go there and beat him twice.

[Dr.Pepper]

Wladimir Klitschko of course.

Not in this Country...or anywhere else than matters.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

My mistake then. He is still generally considered one of the best LW's ever and Floyd did go there and beat him twice.

One of the best Lightweights ever?

Floyd's **** is so far down your throat that somebody is gonna need to perform the Heimlich Maneuver pretty soon.

[Dr.Pepper]

Ray Leonard

[Left Hook Tua]

My mistake then. He is still generally considered one of the best LW's ever and Floyd did go there and beat him twice.

best LW at the time. i don't consider him one of the best LW ever.

still great wins. 1st has been totally exagerrated on how close or good jlc did. floyd won clearly. ppl were just not use to seeing floyd in semi-competitive moments.

[joseph5620]

the dumb indian is not given enough due for being past prime and beating prime pac.

especially after surviving the 3 beatings the great marco antonio barrera gave him.

That first fight between Barrera and Morales was epic.

I was pulling for Barrera pretty hard.

[The Big Dunn]

best LW at the time. i don't consider him one of the best LW ever.

still great wins. 1st has been totally exagerrated on how close or good jlc did. floyd won clearly. ppl were just not use to seeing floyd in semi-competitive moments.

well that's a fair and reasoned point.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

best LW at the time. i don't consider him one of the best LW ever.

still great wins. 1st has been totally exagerrated on how close or good jlc did. floyd won clearly. ppl were just not use to seeing floyd in semi-competitive moments.

That is certainly true of the first Maidana fight but not the first Castillo fight.

Mayweather didn't have the aura around him back then that he does now. There is a very strong case for him losing that fight.

[-PBP-]

like i said pea/roy has 2-3 names that pop out but floyd/pac had more lesser names.

if you choose to not to consider them, that's your opinion. i have mine. OVERALL resume for me goes to pac/floyd. pea could have surpassed both easily with his other big names but he didn't come thru. roy just had no one 175. dariusz would have helped.

Everybody ranked in the top 100 has those lesser names on their resume. Greatness is established from the top of your resume. Floyd and Pac had their chance to get into that category in 2009 but decided not to fight each other.

Hernandez, Corley, Judah, and Canelo are no different than Ramirez, Haugen, Pendleton, Roger Mayweather and Julio Cesar Vazquez to me.