Who is the #1 SMW ever? Jones Jr? Benn? Calzaghe?

[GasPed]

RJJ was unbeatable at SMW, and in his prime, was the best fighter ever in that division.

However, you can't just look at talent - you also have to consider accomplishments when ranking the #1 SMW. In that area, both Calzaghe and Eubank far surpass Jones. My vote for #1 SMW goes to Eubank, based on talent, ability and accomplishments. But if Calzaghe steps up and beats say Kessler and Beyer, he might take my vote.

[supaduck]

Benn might get my vote in terms of sheer excitement and power.

[Easy-E]

this thread is so biased its pathetics.

joe c has one big win
come on now, people

[TheHoff'sGhost]

Jones didnt do much at supermiddle apart from beat a weight drained Toney and his 5 defences were opponents who even ranked in the top 10.
Can someone tell me how he is the best supermiddleweight of all time?

well said

for now its benn
but if calzaghe gets the fights he's after and wins them he comes close

[Southpaw Stinger]

I like Nigel Benn in SMW terms. He might not be THEE greatest but he is my favourite to watch.

[SacTown1]

clearly, it's a 2-man race between Vincenzo Nardiello and Robin Reid

[Undefeated]

RJJ without a doubt.