Who is the #1 SMW ever? Jones Jr? Benn? Calzaghe?

[LemonChiff]

Definately Not Benn, Mcclennan Beat Him By Ko1 Because It Took Benn 14 Seconds To Get Up ,Also Benn Rabbit Punched Everybody And Hit After The Bell.

Juicy You Mention Roy Ducking Everybody, But Roy Said In December 1994 That Chris Eubanks Was The Only Guy Who Can Give Him A Challenge And He Would "love" To Fight Him. Eubanks Turned Down Loads Of Money To Fight Rjj According To Lou Dibella .

[JDizzle79]

was nigel benn ever #1 in his weight-class? I don't remember him being #1 cuz thats when Roy Jones Jr was on the come-up

[LemonChiff]

WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THIS JUICY : http://groups.google.co.uk/group/rec...3ec6aa4df621b6

[quake]

C'mon! Its Roy Jones Jr. Then James Toney! Anyone is not a complete idiot or a flat out racist can see that.

[Xcel]

I am signing on for Calzaghe just yet.. So I would go with Toney and Jones.

[chris_cov]

im going with nigel benn. i cant say roy jones because he never fought benn, eubank, calzaghe etc.

[Moschino045]

its between RJJ & Eubank, i think Eubank was the guy who could of beaten RJJ so ill go with Eubank. JT did'nt do enough at the weight, & we all know eubank would of probably won every round against JT based on styles,

Nige Benn is up there on achievement, ahead of JT, Eubank & RJJ but i think Eubank & RJJ are ahead of him on a 'who beats who' basis. JC is top on achievement u have to say, after the Lacy it has to be JC on achievement as top but he would not of beaten Benn, Eubank or RJJ, i dont know about JT vs JC its kind of me hard for me to visualise lol

[Moschino045]

C'mon! Its Roy Jones Jr. Then James Toney! Anyone is not a complete idiot or a flat out racist can see that.

i guess im an idiot then, or u colour blind (Eubank & Benn are black), JT really did'nt do much at the weight, & would'nt come over here to fight Eubank for good money (who had the style to beat JT every time imo) despite callin out Eubank all the time & trash talkin him. ive not a problem any body saying RJJ is best 168 ever, but just think Eubank did more at the weight than JT did (stopped Watson, drew with Benn- Watson & Benn much better fighters than tim Littles)

[moochi]

man, that list sounds more like best smw for past 20 years........there must have been a smw division before 1990...and being so, there must have been good champs!

[Shanus]

A Calzaghe beats a Eubank, A Eubank beats a Nigel Benn, A Steve Collins beats a Nigel Benn and a Chris Eubank, Roy jones beat nobody.
The answer, Steve Collins vs Joe Calzaghe would have decided.