Who is the #1 SMW ever? Jones Jr? Benn? Calzaghe?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • JuicyJuice
    Banned
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2006
    • 3493
    • 111
    • 4
    • 3,913

    #1

    Who is the #1 SMW ever? Jones Jr? Benn? Calzaghe?

    Here are the candidates..

    Chris Eubank - dug deep inside himself to get Watson out of there, awesome KO of Jarvis, beat Thornton easier than James Toney managed, excellent performance against Rocchigaini in Germany, excellent performance against Wharton, robbed against Collins in their first fight (referee didn't count the knockdown in round two), floored Collins twice (in round two and round 10, Collins had only ever been floored by a body shot beforehand).

    Nigel Benn - bashed up Galvano in Italy, excellent display of head movement and body punching against Piper, smashed Gent over five times (Gent had only been stopped on cuts by big cruiserweights), robbed in Eubank rematch, excellent display of jabbing and head movement against Wharton, climbed back in ring after 30 secs to beat McClellan, robbed against Malinga when Steele called a knockdown in last round when clearly a slip (the way the scoring was Benn would of won, and agents working for Roy Jones were in the crowd ready with the contract for Benn to fight Jones next), made 10 defences of his WBC title.

    James Toney - excellent performance against Barkley, beat the poor mans Marvin Hagler (Thornton), given one more round against undefeated Littles due to cut and got him out of there, got Prince Charles out of there in tough fight.

    Roy Jones - completely dominated and humiliated Toney (although Toney was severely weight-drained), made five defences of his IBF title and sparred with those opponents but somehow managed to avoid Eubank, Benn, McClellan, Nunn, Liles, Collins and Calzaghe.

    Steve Collins - won every round against Eubank in their second fight (although Eubank was burned out and weight-drained), went toe-to-toe with Benn twice and didn't get knocked down.

    Joe Calzaghe - floored Eubank for first time in his life after 10 secs and got through tough fight (although Eubank was rusty and weight-drained), got through tough fight with Brewer, floored for first time in his life against Mitchell but got back up and stopped him that same round, won every minute of every round against Lacy.

    Sven Ottke - controversial decisions against Brewer, Johnson, Mitchell, Starie, Larsen and Reid, but somehow retired unbeaten.

    Well?
    Last edited by JuicyJuice; 03-16-2006, 06:27 AM.
  • JDizzle79
    Skinwalker
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Jan 2006
    • 2279
    • 128
    • 82
    • 9,152

    #2
    it has to come down to calzaghe and jones jr

    Comment

    • JuicyJuice
      Banned
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Jan 2006
      • 3493
      • 111
      • 4
      • 3,913

      #3
      Originally posted by JDizzle79
      it has to come down to calzaghe and jones jr
      I'd have to disagree, a severely weight-drained Toney is not in the class of Eubank and G-Man neither is a severely weight-drained Eubank and a Lacy in the class of Eubank and G-Man.

      I think Nigel stands alone personally.

      Comment

      • JDizzle79
        Skinwalker
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Jan 2006
        • 2279
        • 128
        • 82
        • 9,152

        #4
        but calzaghe and jones jr are still fighting and I'm willing to bet the best is yet to come for the welshman...and he is still undefeated

        Comment

        • medium-deek
          Bet to Win
          Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
          • Jun 2005
          • 5693
          • 517
          • 1,270
          • 14,752

          #5
          Definately Calzaghe. RJJ avoided almost eeryone of note.

          Calzaghe wins hands down as the greatest in the history of SMW. Ever.

          Comment

          • joeboxer
            Black Square
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Nov 2003
            • 3960
            • 260
            • 337
            • 12,264

            #6
            SMW is the division made for hiding away from good fighters at middleweight and light heavy.

            Talking about who is the best SMW is like talking about what is the best fast food chain?

            It might be McDonalds, but it still tastes like ****.

            Comment

            • Bozo_no no
              Palabras de Piedra
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Apr 2005
              • 8906
              • 416
              • 496
              • 16,069

              #7
              Originally posted by medium-deek
              Definately Calzaghe. RJJ avoided almost eeryone of note.

              Calzaghe wins hands down as the greatest in the history of SMW. Ever.
              I like how Jones avoided everyone, and Calzaghe is mentioned in the next sentance. Because, you know, fighting Jeff Lacy makes the fact his entire career up to this year has been a complete waste and showcase of not figthing anyone.

              Comment

              • JDizzle79
                Skinwalker
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jan 2006
                • 2279
                • 128
                • 82
                • 9,152

                #8
                I like taco bell...those ****in baja chicken chalupa's are pproof that God loves us...or me...uuhh...what

                Comment

                • joeboxer
                  Black Square
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Nov 2003
                  • 3960
                  • 260
                  • 337
                  • 12,264

                  #9
                  Originally posted by JDizzle79
                  I like taco bell...those ****in baja chicken chalupa's are pproof that God loves us...or me...uuhh...what

                  I also like Taco Bell. did you know for an extra 25cents you can have all the guacomole and sourcream you want?

                  Comment

                  • JDizzle79
                    Skinwalker
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Jan 2006
                    • 2279
                    • 128
                    • 82
                    • 9,152

                    #10
                    mmmmm, guacamole...I'm hungry

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP