Does Floyd deserve to be #1 lb for lb?

[wmute]

floyd is number one p4p.

he does not have embarassing defeats in his past (pac, winky, barrera), and out of all the unbeaten fighters (hatton, calzaghe, cotto) he is the one with the best opposition

[Dirt E Gomez]

I think the biggest taint mark (heh, that made me laugh) is that he's fighting Zab. A few months ago we were all as giddy as children about that fight between 2 fighters of such a high caliber because we knew it'd be a how. Then Zab goes and ****s it all up by losing to Baldomir and now people will continue to hate on PBF for his weaker competition as of late.

[borikua]

I think the biggest taint mark (heh, that made me laugh) is that he's fighting Zab. A few months ago we were all as giddy as children about that fight between 2 fighters of such a high caliber because we knew it'd be a how. Then Zab goes and ****s it all up by losing to Baldomir and now people will continue to hate on PBF for his weaker competition as of late.

It will be worst if he looses to Zab...Then Baldi will be the man that beat the man that beat THE man...

[Dirt E Gomez]

It will be worst if he looses to Zab...Then Baldi will be the man that beat the man that beat THE man...

Bleh, don't even say such things. Boxing has enough problems as it is at the moment.

[Alibata]

Floyd should be #1 until he loses a fight.

So if he keeps on fighting B level opposition he should retire at the top.

As for Zab, I am not saying he is a chump but a victory againts Zab is now meaningless. Honestly though, how many of y'all would be surprised if Zab won? I am guessin most of us. I wonder why?

[GunStar]

So if he keeps on fighting B level opposition he should retire at the top.

As for Zab, I am not saying he is a chump but a victory againts Zab is now meaningless. Honestly though, how many of y'all would be surprised if Zab won? I am guessin most of us. I wonder why?

PBF resume is better then anyone I can think off, the only guys that has a better resume is Oscarboy at this time & everyone knows I don't like De La Hoya.

Also I will surprised if anyone beats PBF, not just Zab. I think Zab chances are as good as anyone else's.

[AintGottaClue]

i think people put floyd number 1 cause of resume of assorted B level fighters cause he has alot of them, his real only A fighters are corrales castillo maybe jesus chavez

[Easy-E]

So if he keeps on fighting B level opposition he should retire at the top.

As for Zab, I am not saying he is a chump but a victory againts Zab is now meaningless. Honestly though, how many of y'all would be surprised if Zab won? I am guessin most of us. I wonder why?

a victory vs zab is a win against another quality opponent. its not nearly as big as it would be had zab won, but zab is still a quality fighter...

[GunStar]

i think people put floyd number 1 cause of resume of assorted B level fighters cause he has alot of them, his real only A fighters are corrales castillo maybe jesus chavez

Sorry my friend that was self ownage

[Alibata]

PBF resume is better then anyone I can think off, the only guys that has a better resume is Oscarboy at this time & everyone knows I don't like De La Hoya.

Also I will surprised if anyone beats PBF, not just Zab. I think Zab chances are as good as anyone else's.

Yet Oscar aint no lb for lbder. Lb for lb change with every win or loss. I guess the question is what have you done lately? What has PBF done lately? Nobody has answered that question because he really aint done ****. How long has it been? How long will it take?
On the real though, I wouldn't be surprised if PBF got beat. There are fighters out there that have shown to give PBF trouble. Againts Castillo, some people say he lost. He is in a different ball game at this weight. The thing is, I think he is more than good enough to proove to world he is the best. I don't know why he is beating around the bush. Is it the money? Good fights will translate to money and fame. He can ask Morales about that.