Who did you have winning each Pacquiao-Marquez fight?

[IMDAZED]

I don't remember how I scored the first fight but I gave the second to Marquez and the third was a draw IMO. I know that's not the popular opinion but I didn't think it was that much of a blowout for JMM. Will have to watch again.

[b00g13man]

I had it;

1. Draw
2. Marquez (very close)
3. Marquez
4. Obviously Marquez

Yep. This.

[Dr Rumack]

1. Pacquiao
2. Toss-Up
3. Clearly Marquez
4. Even more clearly Marquez

Anyone who says JMM got robbed in the first two is full of shit. They were extremely close fights. The second in particular is almost impossible to call either way.

The third was fairly clear in JMM's favour, as there is no way you can make an argument for Manny in rounds 2-8. He took his foot off the gas going down the stretch, which is a cardinal sin in boxing, but he still won.

[Ray Corso]

Juan stopping Manny was his only win to me. I gave Manny close wins because he made the fights each time and he wasn't being rocked as often as he rocked Juan. Close matches and equally talented but an edge to Manny.
Ray.

[Dr Rumack]

2-2

First fight I had Pac winning by 1 or 2 points

Second fight I had it 6-6 with Pac winning by 1 point because of the knockdown

Third fight I had Marquez winning by 1 or 2 rounds

4th Fight, one of them was going to get knocked out. It just happened to be Pac first.

These 2 guys are dead even. They are split down the middle everytime. One of the greatest rivalries in boxing. I'm glad I got to witness them all.

Pretty much how I see it.

It's a shame the scoring controversy overshadows how great the first two were. They are brilliant fights.

I thought the third was a masterclass in control from Marquez. One of his finest performances in many ways. Just a shame he turned so cautious in the championship rounds. I don't think it mattered too much to the judges, who were seeing the fight for Manny anyway. But in and of itself it was idiotic. Coasting was not an option in a fight like that.

[Bigg Rigg]

3-1 Pacquiao. Juan took his foot off the gas like you said late in the 3rd fight, Nacho telling him he won the fight and advised him to take the 12th round off was a huge mistake.

Jmm Should have lost the first fight cuz the judge made an error scoring rd 1 10-7 instead of 10-6. And I totally agree with him letting up in the 3rd fight. Jmm only won the last fight.

[Evol]

Juan stopping Manny was his only win to me. I gave Manny close wins because he made the fights each time and he wasn't being rocked as often as he rocked Juan. Close matches and equally talented but an edge to Manny.
Ray.

best answer on here, honest and fair.

[Bigg Rigg]

There's no ****ing way Jmm won the second fight. Especially since he was knocked down. If it's 6-6 in rds, with the kd, Manny wins. If it's 7-5 Jmm in rds, its a draw cuz of the kd. So in order for Jmm to win he needs to have been credited for 8 rds right??? Now whose gonna argue that Jmm won 8 rds in the second fight??? If I'm wrong about the scoring system feel free to correct me.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I don't remember how I scored the first fight but I gave the second to Marquez and the third was a draw IMO. I know that's not the popular opinion but I didn't think it was that much of a blowout for JMM. Will have to watch again.

I thought the second fight was the clearest for Marquez too - I had it 8 rounds to 4. The third fight I thought Marquez won too but didn't think it was as wide as people made out, it was the worst of their 4 fights.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

There's no ****ing way Jmm won the second fight. Especially since he was knocked down. If it's 6-6 in rds, with the kd, Manny wins. If it's 7-5 Jmm in rds, its a draw cuz of the kd. So in order for Jmm to win he needs to have been credited for 8 rds right??? Now whose gonna argue that Jmm won 8 rds in the second fight??? If I'm wrong about the scoring system feel free to correct me.

I gave him 8 rounds.

And if it's 7-5 (which I could see), then Marquez wins 114-113. Not a draw.