Who did you have winning each Pacquiao-Marquez fight?

[Bigg Rigg]

I thought the second fight was the clearest for Marquez too - I had it 8 rounds to 4. The third fight I thought Marquez won too but didn't think it was as wide as people made out, it was the worst of their 4 fights.

I agree that the third fight was the worst but I can't see Jmm winning 8 rds in that second fight. Might watch over later but I remember having it 6-6.

[tachie01]

The fans........

Good post!!!

[Bigg Rigg]

You're right about the scoring just did some math right now. Either way I just see it a draw rds wise and Manny winning cuz of the kd.

[Skip Bayless]

1st fight - pac by a few points
2nd fight - very close, cant rememer my score tally but i think i gave it pac by 1 point
3rd fight - marquez easy

[Strategic1]

just curious ..how did you people score Marquez-Barrera? and especially if Barrera was given credit for the knockdown and not penalized.

[SplitSecond]

thank god the judges know how to score most of the time

too many people on here that think a fighter deserves a round because he was the more "careful" and "technical" fighter and grant him a victory due to ring generalship even if he was outlanded

people fall in love with the "swagger", the body language instead of paying attention to the punches landed

[Deevel916]

I have it 2-2 with Pac winning the first 2 and JMM winning 3 and 4. I thought Juan thoroughly outboxed Pac in their 3rd meeting. Pac escaped their 2nd fight with that knockdown. The 3 knockdowns in their first meeting were too much to overcome and had it been scored correctly 6-4 round instead of 7-3 round, Pac would have won.

[dYeyKob]

1. PAC - Close fight
2. Marquez - Clear win
3. PAC - Clear win
4. Marquez - KO

I thought the 3rd fight was the clearest of the 3 fights that was decided on points.

[Matisyahu]

As a fan of Pac's I scored them all three draws. I don't see he ever beat JMM convincingly and I had to give him 3 of the last 4 rounds in the third to arrive at a draw. I could also see splitting them 2-2, as some probably have, in which case I would have the third fight 115-113 JMM. That said, I also think JMM ducked the fifth fight. I was fine with that though b/c I preferred fresh matchups for both.
(Also I'm aware it's technically impossible to score the second a draw w/o even rounds due to the knockdown, but it was that close to warrant a draw IMO.)

[fighter1234]

Juan stopping Manny was his only win to me. I gave Manny close wins because he made the fights each time and he wasn't being rocked as often as he rocked Juan. Close matches and equally talented but an edge to Manny.
Ray.

Just a heads up, that's not how you score fights.