Manny Pacquiao is Undeniably The Greatest Fighter of Our Era

[LouIE G]

Come on... Arturo Gatti is on the HOF because of his entertainment values and warrior mentality and also his tragic death, not because he was an acomplished fighter and you know it.

Yes he was a beloved figure but never was a great fighter.

He was a 2 division world champion wasnt he??? Id say he accomplished something more then just being a beloved figure imo..

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

Why is ranking someone above pac man= to hating on him?????

[LouIE G]

Why is ranking someone above pac man= to hating on him?????

Thats NSB logic 4 ya!

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

Thats NSB logic 4 ya!

lol like damn man i know the guy is great hes an ATG all the way but because i rank floyd above him i hate him, im racist, a dk ryder, and all this other crap???. Then they will post a book full of facts and statistics, and argue you down for 17 days straight... im like "damn man, where did we go wrong?"

[Killer_of_Sheep]

Rocky is fiction, gatti is not..you cant leave a hofer out because you have an agenda against floyd... its not even practical, All Due Respect.

I don't have an agenda against Floyd, really. I just think Manny Pacquiao has a better resume, slighty better at that.

Gatti's inclusion in the hall of fame was mostly because he was such a beloved figure in his time, involved in some of the greatest wars and battles the sport has ever seen, even in defeat. But he was never a special talent, he was a huge lightweight with KO power but he was never a dominant force in the division or in any division he ever fought really.

I love Arturo Gatti, but the discussion here is about who has the better record and legacy. I don't think beating Gatti is that big achievement, really.

[Divine Hammer]

lol like damn man i know the guy is great hes an ATG all the way but because i rank floyd above him i hate him, im racist, a dk ryder, and all this other crap???. Then they will post a book full of facts and statistics, and argue you down for 17 days straight... im like "damn man, where did we go wrong?"

there is no way you can rank floyd above manny. all floyd has is his undefeated record and that's it.

pac won more world titles in more divisions, pac was the first to be lineal champ in 4 weight classes, he has the better resume, fighter of the decade (2000-2009) by BWAA and ring magazine, the more exciting and memorable fighter, fighter of the year 3 times, etc.

pac's one win against bradley is far better than any win floyd has had from 140-147. that is fact.

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

there is no way you can rank floyd above manny. All floyd has is his undefeated record and that's it.

Pac won more world titles in more divisions, pac was the first to be lineal champ in 4 weight classes, he has the better resume, fighter of the decade (2000-2009) by bwaa and ring magazine, the more exciting and memorable fighter, fighter of the year 3 times, etc.

Pac's one win against bradley is far better than any win floyd has had from 140-147. That is fact.

here we go man, im sorry we have different opinions and think differently but no amount of post or emotions will change my opinion this is ****** as hell u need to grow up

[Divine Hammer]

here we go man, im sorry we have different opinions and think differently but no amount of post or emotions will change my opinion this is ****** as hell u need to grow up

what ranks floyd above manny though? if you're going to say that then you should explain yourself.

it can't be because of achievements since manny has accomplished more and it can't be resume since manny's is clearly better. it also can't be because floyd is a better fighter since he refuses to fight pac.

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

what ranks floyd above manny though? If you're going to say that then you should explain yourself.

It can't be because of achievements since manny has accomplished more and it can't be resume since manny's is clearly better. It also can't be because floyd is a better fighter since he refuses to fight pac.

why dont you just dust your feet off as the disciples were commanded when the people didnt listen lol? Dont you think your behavior is a little crazy? A person has a different view point than yours and states they respect yours but you try to force them to change their opinion to make it the same as yours, even after they tell u its not changing, at the end of the day all atg list and pfp rankings are opinion based you cant tell me how my list should be, get over yourself man

[Divine Hammer]

why dont you just dust your feet off as the disciples were commanded when the people didnt listen lol? Dont you think your behavior is a little crazy? A person has a different view point than yours and states they respect yours but you try to force them to change their opinion to make it the same as yours, even after they tell u its not changing, at the end of the day all atg list and pfp rankings are opinion based you cant tell me how my list should be, get over yourself man

ok so you have nothing then.

again, all floyd has is his undefeated record. that's the sad fact for you floyd fan punks.