At what point did you realise Mayweather was a top 10 ATG?

[DosRounds]

He's not even top 100 for me

[Larry the boss]

He's not even top 100 for me

List 100 better fighters

[The Problem Child]

[Outwest Exp 355]

Once PAC ducked him twice.

[- Ram Raid -]

Floyd's the best I've ever seen . . . at what he does.

It's just that what he does . . . is far from being the best I've ever seen.

[siablo14]

What about Never??

He's not even top 100 for me

Where do you guys have Pacquiao ranked?

[ElMeroChingon]

I have Pacquioa higher than Mayweather, Manny has a better resume, alot of great fighters, Mayweathers falls face first in comparison.

[ippo]

wouldn't say top 10 maybe top30 same with pacquiao.They are both not top 10 fighters

[SkillspayBills]

This thread is going to be a 30 pager.

For me it was right after he beat Diego. I knew he had ATG talent. Just needed the resume to back it up.

[#1Assassin]

This thread is going to be a 30 pager.

For me it was right after he beat Diego. I knew he had ATG talent. Just needed the resume to back it up.

this.

floyd was an atg at super featherweight, arguably the best ever and without hesitation top 3. when he beat corrales in the fashion he did he put a stamp on it, that was that. atg.

then going through the weight classes beating champion after champion, HOFer after HOFer and usually with ease. idk if he is top 10 but he is easily top 15 imo.

people like to nitpick but you could do that with basically any fighter, they all have something going against them. that doesnt mean the good things never happened, you have to take the good with the bad and judge the fighters career as a whole. doing so there is no doubt mayweather is one of the best who ever did it.