Mayweather's top 5 wins

[mikinoki]

What had Canelo proved up to that point and it was at a catchweight, so no.

2-3 pounds doesn't really matter.plus not the weight drain beat canelo.It's the skill!!

[Edmond Dantes]

2-3 pounds doesn't really matter.plus not the weight drain beat canelo.It's the skill!!

Bradley's got the better resume, but Canelo was the tougher fight.

[Frank Ducketts]

Torrecampo, Singsurat, Marquez, Morales, and Bradley. Floyd's best wins.

[jcpryor]

I'm just trying to figure out how the TS compares Pacquiao and Mayweather's wins and then in the same breath says he doesn't want it to turn into a Pacquiao/Mayweather thread.

[HonestBoxingFan]

I'm just trying to figure out how the TS compares Pacquiao and Mayweather's wins and then in the same breath says he doesn't want it to turn into a Pacquiao/Mayweather thread.

I told my reasons for making the thread. To compare them. Not because this thread should be about them.

[Luilun]

Corrales is his best win. Every big name he's fought since 2006 has been washed up. Canelo may end up being his best win if he goes on to have a great career.
Imagine..he could have had Margarito,PWill,prime Cotto, and Pacquaio on his resume from 2007-2011.. Nobody ever could have argued that resume added with Corrales and Castillo.

I don't count the Canelo win due to weakening your man to 152. It would have been a great win if it was at 154 not this BS catchweight. Morons who have never boxed or had to cut weight that made them weak need not to response cause you Key Board warriors have no clue in what you ******s utter

[Luilun]

2-3 pounds doesn't really matter.plus not the weight drain beat canelo.It's the skill!!

Try boxing and cut weight to a weight you can barley make than go pick a fight and see if it matters

[HonestBoxingFan]

How can anyone put Alvarez on Mayweather's list of best victories?

Not only was Alvarez drained, he also got robbed against Trout, lost easily to Mayweather and I'm pretty confident that Lara will beat him too.

Corrales is a good win, Hatton is a good win, Castillo is a good win, etc., Alvarez is just an okay win until he improves some more, which there is definitely room for, he's a young guy who is NOT afraid to fight the best.

[daggum]

phillip ndou was his best win. ndou was 31-1 with 30 ko's.

[teddycanyon]

1. Corrales
2. De La Hoya
3. Castillo #2
4. Canelo
5. Judah

The Marquez win looks good on paper but I dock Mayweather a lot of points for failing to make the agreed-upon catchweight after Marquez moved up two weight classes. Honorable mention is bumping off a prime Hatton, decisively beating Shane Mosley who was coming off a demolition of Margarito, taking out a very motivated Miguel Cotto, and winning his first belt against Genaro Hernandez. Gatti was never world class let's be real guys. But Mayweather has a great resume anyway you slice it, it's that one name con****uously missing:PACQUIAO