Mayweather's top 5 wins

[HonestBoxingFan]

Well? Which 5 wins from Mayweather do you see as his best? I'm asking this because Pacquiao, according to me, got two wins that towers above the quality of anyone Floyd fought: Bradley and Barrera. I don't want to make this a Pacquiao-Mayweather thread, we'll never know who's best until they fight, but I just want to see what fans consider to be the greatest wins on Mayweather's record. I want to say that I'm a fan of Floyd and I'm a fan of Manny, no hate intended.

[Jsmooth9876]

Corrales is his best win. Every big name he's fought since 2006 has been washed up. Canelo may end up being his best win if he goes on to have a great career.
Imagine..he could have had Margarito,PWill,prime Cotto, and Pacquaio on his resume from 2007-2011.. Nobody ever could have argued that resume added with Corrales and Castillo.

[Bayles$]

Baldomir
Marquez
Gatti
Mosley
Guerrero

[soul_survivor]

Baldomir
Marquez
Gatti
Mosley
Guerrero

...LOL you are joking right?

Floyd's best win is his only win against a prime fighter at his best weight, coming in and looking strong and that's Castillo.

Corrales was ok but the great fighters Floyd has beaten are Mosley, Oscar, JMM and Cotto, none of them were anywhere near their best, although I give him props for beating Oscar at 154. JMM was fat, Mosley shot and Cotto many years past his best with beatings at the hands of pac and Margy.

So:

Castillo
Oscar
Hatton
Corrales
Hernandez

[jas]

corrales
castillo II
hatton
de la hoya
marquez/canelo/mmosley

[Pago007]

Corrales
Mosley
Hoya
Hatton
Castillo/Canelo

[junior gong]

Ortiz
Guerrero
Maidana
Baldomir
Bruseles

[Edmond Dantes]

Well? Which 5 wins from Mayweather do you see as his best? I'm asking this because Pacquiao, according to me, got two wins that towers above the quality of anyone Floyd fought: Bradley and Barrera. I don't want to make this a Pacquiao-Mayweather thread, we'll never know who's best until they fight, but I just want to see what fans consider to be the greatest wins on Mayweather's record. I want to say that I'm a fan of Floyd and I'm a fan of Manny, no hate intended.

I would say that Mayweather's win over Alvarez is better than Pac's over Bradley.

[junior gong]

I would say that Mayweather's win over Alvarez is better than Pac's over Bradley.

What had Canelo proved up to that point and it was at a catchweight, so no.

[mikinoki]

Pacquaio.....technicaly he beat him by not fighting him and letting marquez do the job....acording to most peoples p4p list