Who has faced better competition? Broner or Golovkin?

[Larry the boss]

Wow Larry , aren't you the same guy that said losses dont count?!

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=632469

Once again trying to own me??lol, read the thread..did i say who has the better resume?? no i said who has faced the better competition...stop trying to be biased...plus Broner has better wins then Golovkin

[dan_cov]

Even taking Maidana out of the equation its quite clearly Broner.

[The Problem Child]

Larry when he makes a new thread



"Me so clever, jail knowledge #Winning"

[brick wall]

broner has the much better resume......and only ggg-tards/pacf@gs will disagree.

not really...broner's resume has a big asterisk with that embarassing loss to maidana.

it's like you applying for job...you submitted your resume with a police certificate that says you robbed your local convenience store. you may have a better experiences than the other applicants but you won't get the job.

[jas]

Once again trying to own me??lol, read the thread..did i say who has the better resume?? no i said who has faced the better competition...stop trying to be biased...plus Broner has better wins then Golovkin

OK, fair enough.

[Xi_]

i prefer pacfarts, thank you kind sir

There is a difference one is more extreme than the other.....I don't think you're either one for the record.

[Larry the boss]

larry when he makes a new thread



"me so clever, jail knowledge #winning"

why would you put someone on ignore then come in their thread?

[Xi_]

not really...broner's resume has a big asterisk with that embarassing loss to maidana.

it's like you applying for job...you submitted your resume with a police certificate that says you robbed your local convenience store. you may have a better experiences than the other applicants but you won't get the job.

Has GGG beat the number one guy in his division? Has GGG gone up a division and faced a top 10 or even a top 15 guy? Losing to maidana is no embarrassment, maidana is a good fighter who has been competitive in 99% of his fights against competition that GGG hasn't even sniffed yet. GGG doesn't compare to broner.....at all!

[JBell11]

Interesting point you are attempting to make (broner has the better resume) but unfortunately leads to an unbalanced analysis. Other questions need to be asked if you want to make a fair comparison of these two:

Who has had the most difficulty against mediocre competition?
Who has demonstrated superior skill and future potential?

These questions amongst others lead to the conclusion that Golovkin is the superior fighter.

Exactly! The thread is a loaded question both haven't really proven themselves. Not that it's a bad question but both aren't nessesarily fighting competitive fights...(with the exception of Maidana).
I'd have to say Broner though.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Has GGG beat the number one guy in his division? Has GGG gone up a division and faced a top 10 or even a top 15 guy? Losing to maidana is no embarrassment, maidana is a good fighter who has been competitive in 99% of his fights against competition that GGG hasn't even sniffed yet. GGG doesn't compare to broner.....at all!

The difference is that Golovkin can't get certain fights because of politics/reluctance and whatnot.

Not one mother***er is reluctant to fight Broner.