Comments Thread For: Pound For Pound Update: Mayweather Still Undefeated

[Nightfall]

Floyd shouldn't even be on that list after losing to maidana. An 18-1 underdog.

Without flod. There is no list. Get out of here little boy and go tag along to a play ground.

[IronDanHamza]

Still active enough for me to look first and how good he is. I mean, it's not that much more inactive than lots of guys.


Gonzalez is a fantastic fighter with more than enough quality wins to compliment the eye test. Special talent. I can see where one would disagree, but that is sort of the point of this whole exercise.

Ward has two fights since 2011, both worthless. Don't consider that P4P stuff.

Gonzalez doesn't have that many quality wins. No where near enough to be Top 5 P4P anyway.

Good fighter though.

Subjective obviously but struggle to see how that can be justified.

[IronDanHamza]

chino should be on this list since he beat mayweather, at least in the eyes of many


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

Since when is 8% "many"?

[Weebler I]

I think Ward's the best on the list but he should be dropped a place or three.

In the past 20 months, he has only beat an unproven Edwin Rodriguez to a UD in his backyard.

[chargerhemi06]

Without flod. There is no list. Get out of here little boy and go tag along to a play ground.

Lol...another butthurt Floyd fan. Mission accomplished in this thread.

[crold1]

Ward has two fights since 2011, both worthless. Don't consider that P4P stuff.

Gonzalez doesn't have that many quality wins. No where near enough to be Top 5 P4P anyway.

Good fighter though.

Subjective obviously but struggle to see how that can be justified.

Not everyone regards Gonzalez as highly as I do, often for the same reason. I think the goods are just that clear. That said, I also think Yaegashi's hand speed could give him some fits and look forward to that fight. I suspect Gonzalez will soon be the champ in the best (or next best) division in boxing.

[-Makunouchi-]

I agree with cliff having gonzales at top 5, boxing these days does not give **** on the lower weights, to those who dont know gonzales try watching his fights, hes a tough s.o.b.

[Radical]

Floyd's **** performance against Maidana is like Pacquiao losing 6 rounds to Brandon Rios.

quite frankly its embarrassing. For someone who claims to be the "best ever" and is regarded as the best defensive fighter, best counter puncher in boxing there are certain standards that need to be met with those accolades.

[beast702]

I don't see how Martinez is ranked 9 I think he should be at least be at 5 or 6. Rigo needs to be dropped a few. Froch off the list replaced by Bhop. Wladimir gets absolutely no credit Idc how boring he is dominant. Have him replace Gonzalez. Danny be at 10 after that awful showing against Herrera. 1. May 2. Ward(dude needs to be more active) 3. Pac 4. Wlad 5. Martinez 6. Rigo 7. Bradley 8. Marquez 9. Bhop 10. Garcia

[Luilun]

So Floyds number 1 but he got beat up by a guy who's not even on the list, Ward hasn't fought since when ? Pacquiao should be move up to number 1 Madaina should be number 2, with Floyd number 3 and Ward number 4 for inactivity and not fighting the big Guns of 175