Comments Thread For: Pound For Pound Update: Mayweather Still Undefeated

[Luilun]

There have been changes in the months since the last update but one thing remains the same: Floyd Mayweather is still undefeated.

It was closer this time though.

Mayweather had his hands full with rugged Marcos Maidana in their Welterweight unification tilt and had to call on all his skills to forge his latest win. Was the competitive contest enough to move the top slot?

Below Mayweather, Manny Pacquiao moves up on the force of his win over Timothy Bradley while Bradley’s loss sees him slip a spot behind the best fighter in the world most of the US isn’t seeing.
[Click Here To Read More]

Bigpapapump should change his picture to Madaina since he became Floyds Papa that night

[crold1]

I don't see how Martinez is ranked 9 I think he should be at least be at 5 or 6. Rigo needs to be dropped a few. Froch off the list replaced by Bhop. Wladimir gets absolutely no credit Idc how boring he is dominant. Have him replace Gonzalez. Danny be at 10 after that awful showing against Herrera. 1. May 2. Ward(dude needs to be more active) 3. Pac 4. Wlad 5. Martinez 6. Rigo 7. Bradley 8. Marquez 9. Bhop 10. Garcia

Wlad was there at 10 for a long time but the Povetkin performance cost him. I have an eye on his next few challenges. The rest of the divisions are just so much better than heavyweight, that gets hard to overlook. heavyweight looking up though.

[Shambrolic]

To be real why is Pacquiao in the top 5? This is a guy who a year and a month ago was knocked unconsciously face flat looking like he tucking his nuts in the ring.

No P4P great has ever been knocked out unconscious on the floor for 5mins+, that's a major problem how they give Pacquiao a pass and keep him in the top 10.

Also before anyone go and say he's been stopped by someone on the P4P list so that is why, you forget the only reason Marquez was even in the P4P list was because there was quite a following of people who thought he beat Pacquiao in their 2008 match up(during Floyd's retirement), that's how JMM entered the list at #2 P4P as it was the intriguing match up to make. Same thing with Bradley he became #8 on the P4P list because of his defeat of Pacquiao. These two guys are only in the list because Pacquiao is overrated and given some type of status where if anyone give him trouble they get on the list.... so basically when he was troubled by actual competition (that's not plodding forward and can't box) they rated these guys P4P.

That is a major error and oversight.. He fights dead-men who use to have names to give himself some look of legend and then when he fights someone alive, he gets exposed, which puts them on the P4P list.

[mellymel3015]

What up ppl, just a quick question! I'm fairly new to posting up here so forgive me if I'm not following procedures or whatever. As a die hard boxing fan and also a fan of Mayweather's, I was just wondering why he gets so much hate for not having his best night against Chino? I mean the guy is human, and at any given night anything can happen in that ring.

I can admit that his performance was nothing close to what we are accustomed to seeing from him, but we have to give Maidana credit, he came in with no fear and showed no respect to Floyd, and made it a tough fight. Can anyone name a fighter that has never looked bad or faced adversity in the ring at some point in their career? Yes he calls himself "TBE" and thinks very highly of his skills, but imo that doesn't mean that you can't have a bad night. Hell, we've all had bad days at our jobs, doesn't mean we can't still be great at it. IDK, what are y'alls thoughts?

[crold1]

To be real why is Pacquiao in the top 5? This is a guy who a year and a month ago was knocked unconsciously face flat looking like he tucking his nuts in the ring.

No P4P great has ever been knocked out unconscious on the floor for 5mins+, that's a major problem how they give Pacquiao a pass and keep him in the top 10.

Also before anyone go and say he's been stopped by someone on the P4P list so that is why, you forget the only reason Marquez was even in the P4P list was because there was quite a following of people who thought he beat Pacquiao in their 2008 match up(during Floyd's retirement), that's how JMM entered the list at #2 P4P as it was the intriguing match up to make. Same thing with Bradley he became #8 on the P4P list because of his defeat of Pacquiao. These two guys are only in the list because Pacquiao is overrated and given some type of status where if anyone give him trouble they get on the list.... so basically when he was troubled by actual competition (that's not plodding forward and can't box) they rated these guys P4P.

That is a major error and oversight.. He fights dead-men who use to have names to give himself some look of legend and then when he fights someone alive, he gets exposed, which puts them on the P4P list.

Plenty of all time greats have been screwed into the floor with the right shot. Duran, Jones, and Fullmer to name a few.

[Shambrolic]

Duran was knocked out by a guy weight classes above him..

Pacquiao always been knocked out by people lighter than him.

Gene Fullmer also was knocked out by P4P himself.

[crold1]

Duran was knocked out by a guy weight classes above him..

Pacquiao always been knocked out by people lighter than him.

Gene Fullmer also was knocked out by P4P himself.

Duran was fighting what was supposed to be a unification fight in a division where he won a title. Hearns was a bad match. They were both Jr. Middles at the time. Outside of Marquez, there were conditions to the other two stops. Pac's first stop loss was arguably not even on a punch. Low blow/headbutt simultaneous. Medgoen he was drained dead trying to make 112 and missed and went down on a so-so body shot. Marquez and he are roughly the same size and always have been. They've always been evenly matched. You're nitpicking one of the best fighters of the last 20 years.

[mrpizza-nd_beer]

I think the list is ridiculous. Too much zero loss worship. But you definitely are entitled to your opinion.

[NELSONMELENDEZ2]

I agree

I agree with most of this list.

[kingfaze19]

chino should be on this list since he beat mayweather, at least in the eyes of many


Posted from Boxingscene.com App for Android

many = nobody. he lost, shut up already, his own countryman Matthysse said he lost.