How did you score Mayweather vs Maidana?

[Daddy T]

So I have rewatched the fight. Had floyd 7-5 first time around. With commentary turned off and concentrating more had it 114-114.

[k1llu]

somehow people should try to rewatch it without showtime hyping floyds every freking punch
i have it a draw i might have it a win for maidana without the annoiying showtime hype machine

I'm watching the fight in 1080p as i type anybody who gives miadana more than 4 rounds is fucking ******ed

[radioraheem]

Floyd won. Maidana lost. Whats the debate here. In boxing you need more than 4 rounds to win the fight. You kids haven't learned from the cotto fight huh?

Winning 4 rounds vs Mayweather is not a moral victory.

Are you surprised? They still talk about Shane Mosley's 2nd round.

[Suckmedry]

Go back and watch footage. Lamotta, who deserves all the props he gets, was more or less a slow come forward fighter, who was relentless. Not much difference. He made Robinson struggle.

Lamotta lost tons of fights to low level fighters. He definitely wasn't an A-level guy, not an elite fighter of that era.

Lamotta was relatively slow, and not the biggest puncher, but yes he was absolutely relentless, and had underrated skills and ability. You clearly don't know what you are Talking about. This is the guy who halted the greatest fighter Evers undefeated streak. He would be the middleweight king If he was fighting today.

[punchr]

7-4, 1 even Maidana.

[Fetta]

Maidana 1,3,4,6 & 8

7-5 Floyd

Ive watched it now 5 times.

[Radical]

Floyd's punches werent very powerful or effective. he was basically slapping.

not impressed by Floyd's defense or offense at all but i have no problem with the decision.

i dont have a problem with maidana winning as well after viewing it a 3rd time

[IronDanHamza]

Go back and watch footage. Lamotta, who deserves all the props he gets, was more or less a slow come forward fighter, who was relentless. Not much difference. He made Robinson struggle.

Lamotta lost tons of fights to low level fighters. He definitely wasn't an A-level guy, not an elite fighter of that era.

Lamotta is definitely an elite fighter of that era and an A level fighter.

[Bring It On]

8-4 Mayweather.

[V.WEBB]

8-4 Mayweather after watching it again. But it was about the same thing I thought watching live. I rarely score fights live since I usually throw big parties for the big PPV. Not of, I had over 20 people at my house, and it was loud, etc. Thought Floyd won a close, tough fight live, and rewatching affirmed that.

Gave Chino Rounds 1,4,5,8 if I'm not mistaken, wrote it down at home. But from round 6 ahead (save round 8), I thought Floyd threw more punches and landed pretty much at will. He did good body work too.