Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How did you score Mayweather vs Maidana?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • 8-4 Mayweather. you cant score a fight based on punch thrown they have to actually land.

    Comment


    • Originally posted by Still Burner View Post
      Floyd won. Maidana lost. Whats the debate here. In boxing you need more than 4 rounds to win the fight. You kids haven't learned from the cotto fight huh?

      Winning 4 rounds vs Mayweather is not a moral victory.
      Not a good comparison bra bra

      Comment


      • Maidana 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 8, 12
        Mayweather 6, 7, 9, 10, 11

        Body work is what slowed Floyd down NOT because he wanted to grace us with a brawl as he claims.

        Maidana's jab and feints kept Mayweather at bay; Maidana's defense is better than people think.

        Give credit to Garcia for introducing the jab into Chino's arsenal. That was the deciding factor in the fight along with the constant body work. The left hook to the body paid off huge along with the thudding rights.

        "Dirty" fight on BOTH sides though. Neither side can complain as there were numerous elbows to the face, over hooking of arms, and low blows.

        Clearly any boxer who can keep constant pressure and has a decent beard will smother Floyd for long stretches and nullify him just like Maidana did. Good fight but if he intends on fighting only three more times it should be some fresh matchup's:

        1. Khan - interesting match up due to the speed but Khan's chin might betray him

        2. Pacquiao - clearly; but don't think he has the punch resistance currently that would be needed to absorb some of those sneaky right hands and uppercuts

        3. Thurman/Porter/Garcia/Bradley - fantasy tourney for a shot at Mayweather

        Comment


        • Originally posted by 4Corners View Post
          I don't think it was so much Floyd looked slower or older, his hand speed and foot speed was the same.

          Maidana just fought a much smarter fight then Guerrero or Canelo. They let Floyd do his thing in the middle of the ring, Guerrero smothered all his work on the ropes.

          Maidana really had success the first 6 rounds, though Floyd still landed often as well, particularly the 2nd where I felt he won the round, and the 5th. Floyd then took over the 2nd half. Take the beer goggles off, and tell me who landed most of the punches rounds 7-12.....it was Floyd clearly, though Chino still made him work.
          Canelo and Guerrero naturally fight better going backwards or fighting in the middle of the ring. This is why they were very ineffective vs Mayweather. Maidana's natural style is to come forward and be as awkward as possible, I had it a draw but I can't object to either guy winning on anybody's card, the fight had a lot of those weird rounds

          anybody else starting to see a trend with Floyd, when he gets frustrated he tends to exchange/trade with his opponent, he did it vs Mosley, Ortiz, Cotto and Maidana last night

          Comment


          • round 1: Maidana
            round 2: Mayweather
            round 3: Maidana
            round 4: Maidana(close rd)
            round 5: Maidana (hurt floyd momentarily too)
            round 6: Maidana (Very close rd, Maidana beat the crap out of floyd for a full 2 minutes and 30 seconds, floyd did some nice work in the last 30 seconds of the rd, besides that, did nothing besides a nice uppercut earlier, gave it to maidana due to his overall body of work)
            round 7: Mayweather
            round 8: Maidana (rolled/slipped majority of mayweather's punches, worked the hell out of floyds body, landed a beautiful hook and overhand)
            round 9: Mayweather (clear round, maidana did nothing, floyd landed alot)
            round 10: Mayweather
            round 11: Mayweather
            round 12: Mayweather (really close rd, mayweather was more consistent, so i gave it to him)

            draw or should the sixth be given to floyd, mayweather by a point

            Comment


            • Meant to vote 7-5 Maidana..

              Comment


              • I had the fight a draw at 114-114. I would like to see the rematch immediately.

                Floyd Mayweather vs. Marcos Maidana II
                Danny Garcia vs. Lucas Matthysse II
                Peter Quillin vs. Daniel Jacobs
                Omar Figueroa vs. Jorge Linares

                I'd buy that card right now, or hell even drive from LA to Vegas to go see it.

                Comment


                • I had Maidana winning by 2 points.

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by k1llu View Post
                    8-4 Mayweather. you cant score a fight based on punch thrown they have to actually land.
                    Pretty much this.

                    I don't understand all this talk about bodywork.

                    Maidana's shots to the body were either smothered, blocked, or landed on Floyd's back (which is -not- a legal or clear shot).

                    As a side note, I'm surprised Maidana was't taken a point off after his blatant attempt to knee Floyd , not to mention the rabbit punches.

                    El chino fought like a leaner (rip) Tony Galento. Ballsy display, but no way he won.

                    Comment


                    • somehow people should try to rewatch it without showtime hyping floyds every freking punch
                      i have it a draw i might have it a win for maidana without the annoiying showtime hype machine

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP