How'd you score it, was it a robbery?

[Radical]

7-5 floyd

maidana threw away the fight the last 4 rounds

[Roy Jones Jnr]

No robbery at all IMO.

Had Mayweather winning 8 rounds to 4.

[Prime 407]

I had it a draw, if the ref had warned or taken a point off Floyd for excessive holding then things would have gotten really interesting!

[Enzo Mc is SHIT]

I had it a draw, if the ref had warned or taken a point off Floyd for excessive holding then things would have gotten really interesting!

It's a fair point and there was a time when I was screaming at the TV for Weeks to take a point but then there was a number of indiscretions from Maidana too.

[M Bison]

I had it 7-5 Maidana.

Could have been 6-6 or 7-5 either way. Great fight. Need a rematch.

Same as you

[IronDanHamza]

Based on what?

Maidana dictated the pace of the fight for the first 6 rounds and out-threw Mayweather 2-1. You can give me the spiel about how Maidana was hitting arms and gloves, but it's not going to change my scoring. Mayweather didn't even show up until round 7, IMO.

In most of the early rounds Maidana doubled Floyd's output and completely controlled the pace at which the fight was being fought. More important than that, he looked comfortable with what he was doing in there while Mayweather was lobby'ing the referee for help and handouts every chance he got.

I don't have a problem with your scoring because I realize that scoring is subjective, but if you're going to call my scoring into question? Well, that's bull****.

No I'm asking you how can you say that he won "atleast 4" of the first 6? He didn't win "atleast 4"

Can I see him getting 4 of the first 6? Yes of course but he didn't win "atleast" 4. He didn't clearly win 4 of the first 6.

Like I said 2, 4 and 6 could easily have been scored for Mayweather and 3 wasn't a clear round either.

[NAPO]

Apart from all the crazy awkward punches from Maidana, he threw a great jabs. He had Mayweather confuse. 114-114 or 115-114 Mayweather.

[No Tomorrow]

No Thurman will not

We will see.

Think Thurman presents a style Mayweather has never dealt with.

Mayweather usually fights aggressive come straight forward guys but there have been times where he versus a guy who's more of a "boxer" style he's run into some difficult. E.G.

Chop Chop hurting him and being competitive
Shane rocking him (though Shane was clearly faded and is more of a swarmer-puncher, but does have some what of a boxer style to him)
Burton (who Floyd said was his toughest fight)
Zab (dropping Floyd - although it wasnt scored a KD - and Zab won a decent amount of rounds)

I think Thurman is better and more dangerous than all of them.

And I expect Thurman to play the upset role like a Chris Weidman/Antonio Tarver

I am pretty confident but we shall see

[ßringer]

No I'm asking you how can you say that he won "atleast 4" of the first 6? He didn't win "atleast 4"

Can I see him getting 4 of the first 6? Yes of course but he didn't win "atleast" 4. He didn't clearly win 4 of the first 6.

Like I said 2, 4 and 6 could easily have been scored for Mayweather and 3 wasn't a clear round either.

Pardon me.

I didn't know that I'd have to point out that when I say "at least" I'm talking about my own scorecard.

I don't see your score, though. I gave Maidana rounds 3 and 6. Fairly convincingly, too. Couple that with rounds 1 and 5 (which I also gave to Maidana), and there you have my card for the first half of the fight.

Floyd didn't show up until round 7.

Scorecards are subjective, though. Like I said, I had Mayweather winning 7-5. So I don't really see what you're debating me about, as we had the same outcome.

[I Love Jesus!]

Really close fight, I would have been happy with a draw and an immediate rematch, Floyd keeps his 0 and title so does Miadana.

To me Floyds stand out rounds were 6-7-9 and maybe the end of 12. Didn't score the first half but I know it was close with Miadana out working but with Mayweather landing the much more precise shots