Shawn Porter vs. Kell Brook: Who Wins?

[just the facts]

Brook's going to smash Porter to pieces.

Which fights on Brooks or Porters resume leads you to believe this?

[JACK1190]

You don't live in Pagehall do you?

Brook gets a good beating and I cant wait. I will make sure I get a ringside seat to see his ass getting plastered.

Porter couldn't sell a ticket even if he paid people to come to the fight lol!

[AntonTheMeh]

i like somethings about brook's look as a fighter, but he would get hurt bad by porter.

[BrokenHat]

Brook cannot box.

He relies on combos to keep his opponents from attacking him, but he has little defensive technique other than that.

I hope Porter beats Brook into mental ******ation, so we can be done with this Mike Jones wannabe coward.

[kombayn]

Well it seems everyone has jumped on the Shawn Porter train, I think he would crush Kell Brook but I won't be surprised if Kell Brook ducks the fight or Shawn Porter moves up to 154lbs because he had a lot of trouble getting down to 147lbs for his fight with Paulie.

For those who will cry foul about a Thurman vs. Porter match-up, the thing is that Thurman is a natural 154lbs like Porter. I think if those two fight each other it will be at the Jr. Middleweight division.

[sicko]

I like both but I think Porter would be too strong for Kell Inside and I don't think Kell has the skills inside or the footwork to keep his distance from Porter to get off his Punches. I think Kell struggles more when he does fight off of his back foot and he can't fight inside AT ALL

So Porter by Late Stoppage! Haven't seen enough Improvement from Kell to be honest and that is against Average or Below Average Competition so what happens when he does Step Up Competition

[BrokenHat]

Well it seems everyone has jumped on the Shawn Porter train, I think he would crush Kell Brook but I won't be surprised if Kell Brook ducks the fight or Shawn Porter moves up to 154lbs because he had a lot of trouble getting down to 147lbs for his fight with Paulie.

For those who will cry foul about a Thurman vs. Porter match-up, the thing is that Thurman is a natural 154lbs like Porter. I think if those two fight each other it will be at the Jr. Middleweight division.

Porter won't vacate now.

But if Brook does duck the fight, good god.

[kombayn]

Porter won't vacate now.

But if Brook does duck the fight, good god.

I think Porter will vacate if they give him a title shot against Lara (who will still be champ win or lose against Canelo) or Carlos Molina (Golden Boy still has 1 option on him).

If you watched the weigh-in, Shawn Porter was late because he was still trying to shed weight and the announcer made big light of that followed by the fact he had to go completely nude to weigh-in which he was .2 under the limit.

I'm pretty sure Shawn Porter only has a couple more fights left in him at Welterweight before he jumps up to the Jr. Middleweight division.

[ATG Fighter]

I would definitely expect Porter to batter Brook. Never seen anything special in Kell Brook. Forget being skilled (which he isn't), he isn't even very talented imo.

Would be very shocked to see Brook win

[IronDanHamza]

I would definitely expect Porter to batter Brook. Never seen anything special in Kell Brook. Forget being skilled (which he isn't), he isn't even very talented imo.

Would be very shocked to see Brook win

Exactly I don't see this "talent" either.

How is he talented? I genuinely would like to know.

He's not remotely fast, infact he's pretty damn slow. His reflexes aren't fast, he has solid power at best, he's no monster puncher.