Hagler vs Toney: Who Wins?

[wmute]

I agree with juyjuy:

the younger hagler beats toney, but the "reign of terror" hagler loses to toney

[Zab Super Judah]

hagler would pound the body of toney. And he would be able to hit toney but Toneys hand speed would help him out a bit. I got to go with MR hagler by close but clear decision

[neverlast]

McCallum would have been a very tough fight for Marv but I see Hagler coming out on top. Mc Callum in my eyes was an all time top 20. Very under rated. He was not flashy but he was a very complete fighter.

Hagler would have had trouble early with a prime Michael Nunn. I just see Marvin doing what he did best...Outwilling and outfighting his foe.

[GunStar]

Hagler would butt **** Toney at middleweight or super middleweight.

That little mongoose wouldn't work against Hagler's ruthless body and head attack. He would wear toney out and stop him, or he would just pound a decision out on his ass.

Toney might recieve a gift....but I doubt it.

Two different levels of fighters.

Lol, you must be the biggest ****** on this board. First thing Hagler is my favorite fighter of all time. Noway in hell Hagler or any other middleweight would've ever stopped Toney. This shows how much you really know

[Zab Super Judah]

Lol, you must be the biggest ****** on this board. First thing Hagler is my favorite fighter of all time. Noway in hell Hagler or any other middleweight would've ever stopped Toney. This shows how much you really know

I DONT THINK A PRIME and PHYSICALLY FIT TONEY would ever be stopped. As in he didnt starve himself to make weight.

[GunStar]

I DONT THINK A PRIME and PHYSICALLY FIT TONEY would ever be stopped. As in he didnt starve himself to make weight.

Exactly! Both Hagler & Toney had some of the best chins you will ever see in the middleweights. Actually Toney still has a great chin as a HW.

[WindUpMerchant]

Didn't you see what happened to a disinterested Toney when Reggie Johnson dropped AND cut up Toney?

[Zab Super Judah]

Didn't you see what happened to a disinterested Toney when Reggie Johnson dropped AND cut up Toney?

yeah but the question was a PRIME AND PHYSICALLY FIT TONEY vs HAGLER. not a disinterested toney vs hagler

[WindUpMerchant]

The 80's were the last era in which the fighters were truly schooled. Hagler's pressure would get to Toney and he would stop him late.

[GunStar]

Didn't you see what happened to a disinterested Toney when Reggie Johnson dropped AND cut up Toney?

Was Toney ever hurt??? The answer to that is a big NOOOOOOOOOOOO!