Had Calzaghe not ducked America
Collapse
-
-
Yeah he definitely priced himself out of fights. But it certainly wasn't because he was avoiding any fighters. In the end, however, he was the big winner.Comment
-
No, they weren't. Joe was champ, making money. Just as hop and Roy. All this "you need to come to america to make it", is bs. The only people who really believe that crap are ignorantly arrogant Americans. The title is "World" champ. Not american champ.Originally posted by robertzimmermanBerry Picker,
Quote:
World" champs Hops and Roy could have fought in other parts of the world too you know? america isn't the world and never will be.
Roy and Bernard never really had to leave America.
Their circumstances were different to Joe's.
Posted from Boxingscene.com App for AndroidComment
-
Its the same. Dude was sparked out. Roy obviously chose the easiest hw to "make history" with.Originally posted by robertzimmermanBerry Picker,
Quote:
How many years earlier was Ruiz destroyed when Roy fought him?
How is that relevant to this discussion?
Completely different circumstances. Ruiz was caught by Tua at HW. He then won a belt, and became a top 5 guy.
Roy then moved up and beat him.
How is that the same as Joe not wanting to fight a washed up Roy, who'd been knocked out twice, and was nearly 40, only to then change his mind and take the fight?
Posted from Boxingscene.com App for AndroidComment
-
No, it's where protected US fighters refuse to leave (with so called stars blatantly roiding up). There's a difference. A fighter can be the best anywhere but he's forced to go to his opponent's backyard when his opponent is too cowardly to leave, even when a good financial deal is on the table. The football analogy doesn't work because there's money both sides of the Atlantic in boxing.Hatton and Calzaghe can't become the best unless they come here. The reason Hatton and other foreign fighters come to the US is the same reason US soccer players go outside of the US to play-its where the best are.
If a US player tries to become the best he can't do it just competeing in whatever the US soccer league is. I think we'd agree beating the Red Bulls is slightly less significant than beating Man U.
Its not about home cooking its about competition.
But hey, karma comes in the form of the new wave of European fighters, KO-artists, no judging needed. The future of US boxing is European and Mexican, the next generation of star names and it's just what those arrogant fans who refuse to see boxing as a global sport deserve.Last edited by Weebler I; 04-09-2014, 01:55 PM.Comment
-
Exactly. Dudes want ALL the hometown advantages. Why not meet in a neutral country? american fighters could easily agree to that. But they rarely if ever do.Originally posted by Weebler IQuote:
Originally Posted by LarryXXX
Hopkins nor Roy were jumping to fight him either to be fair
and Mayweather was in no hurry to travel to the UK when Hatton was the man at 140 after beating Tszyu, "I ain't goin to England" was the cry from little Floyd.
These cnuts all love their home advantage for good reason, but none more self-entitled than the fans of US fighters who think it's their God-given right to fight at home with pet refs, and promoters jobbing opponents with corrupt judging.
"You got to come to America to fight" [to suit the US fighter] - Sturm had the right idea after getting robbed, he never went back.
Posted from Boxingscene.com App for AndroidComment
-
Money, maybe. Respect, no. Thats the analogy I made with the soccer player.No, it's where protected US fighters refuse to leave (with so called stars blatantly roiding up). There's a difference. A fighter can be the best anywhere but he's forced to go to his opponent's backyard when his opponent is too cowardly to leave, even when a good financial deal is on the table. The football analogy doesn't work because there's money both sides of the Atlantic in boxing.
But hey, karma comes in the form of the new wave of European fighters, KO-artists, no judging needed. The future of US boxing is European and Mexican, the next generation of star names.
Where are these huge paydays? In some isolated cases yes, but when we are talking the biggest fights, no.
We will see. We don't know. All we know is Bob signed a ton of non US olympians and HBO is hevaily investing in Kovalev and GGG.Comment
-
Dirk Diggler UK,
Joe wouldn't raise his profile by talking to the media and doing publicity stuff. Frank W has said that. He wasn't willing to push himself.Ricky Hatton had 40 fights before he fought Tsyzu. Only then did he go across to America and he was given big money to do so because of his following.
It's easy to say Calzaghe should have "worked his way up the rankings" but the guy was already a world champion and making good money in the UK. It's unrealistic to say he should go to America and make less with the hope of one day facing Jones which may have never happened anyway. I remember Steve Collins jumping in the ring after one of Roy's fights to call him out and he never got the fight.
He was willing to go to America to fight Hopkins as early as 2002 but Bernard walked away from the deal.
It's ok to say he was a world champion, but he was unknown outside of Europe. He was a great fighter. But he fought in a weak division, defending a belt that wasn't respected or even ranked by the likes of the Ring magazine.
You seem to be missing the point.
Without doing what Ricky Hatton did, which was to raise his profile and move up a division, he was never going to get a shot at Roy.
It's as simple as that.
Now you've given valid reasons as to why he didn't, and I can see where you're coming from. I can see things from yours and Joe's perspective.
It was a safer bet for him to stay at in Britain.
I've no problem with it. But I'm just telling you that's why he never got the fight when it mattered.
Steve Collins was overlooked in the mid 90's at 168, because Roy couldn't unify the division. So he moved up to 175 and Collins got left behind. Then in 99, when Collins got in the ring with Roy, HBO had no interest in making a fight between them. They wanted Roy to unify with Reggie Johnson instead, and that's what happened. But just because Roy wouldn't fight Collins, it didn't mean that he wouldn't have fought Joe if it made sense to him. Roy was happy to fight him in 2008, because it was his last shot at the top, with a good payday. But earlier on, Roy always had better options. So you can't use Collins as any sort of evidence to say that Roy wouldn't have fought Joe. The circumstances were different.
With regards to Hopkins in 2002, again I don't believe it was a simple duck. Bernard fought at a different weight, and pulled out of the three fight deal. But Joe could have tried to have fought in America regardless. Every other top British fighter did.Last edited by robertzimmerman; 04-09-2014, 05:46 PM.Comment
-
Weebler I,
A top American fighter who fights for the worlds biggest promoters, on TV's biggest networks etc, doesn't need to travel. It's always been the same.and Mayweather was in no hurry to travel to the UK when Hatton was the man at 140 after beating Tszyu, "I ain't goin to England" was the cry from little Floyd.
These cnuts all love their home advantage for good reason, but none more self-entitled than the fans of US fighters who think it's their God-given right to fight at home with pet refs, and promoters jobbing opponents with corrupt judging.
"You got to come to America to fight" [to suit the US fighter] - Sturm had the right idea after getting robbed, he never went back.
Do you think Mike Tyson in the 80's would have come to England to fight Frank Bruno?
Why would Floyd have come for Hatton, when he didn't need to?Comment
-
Berry Picker,
Roy and Bernard were unified champs. Nearly all of their competition were based in America. Roy fought on HBO, and Hopkins fought on HBO and Showtime with King.No, they weren't. Joe was champ, making money. Just as hop and Roy. All this "you need to come to america to make it", is bs. The only people who really believe that crap are ignorantly arrogant Americans. The title is "World" champ. Not american champ.
They didn't need to leave America.
Once again, Joe's circumstances were different. Roy was considered the best fighter on the planet. Which meant that he held all the cards. He had the power in negotiations. Joe was relatively unknown, and fought in a weak division, holding a lightly regarded belt.
Boxing is a business.
Joe needed to travel to enhance his career.
But Roy and Bernard didn't need to.
Throughout history, many, many top fighters have travelled to America to progress their careers.
The majority of the worlds biggest fights are staged in America, and it's always been that way.
The biggest fights have nearly all been in Vegas at the casinos.Last edited by robertzimmerman; 04-09-2014, 06:06 PM.Comment

Comment